Lots of dark, tart plum and blue berry upfront, converting into into a mineral earthiness on the mid palette and settling in a balanced, lingering vibrant finish with fine polished fully integrated tannins. Full body, but lacking evolving layers of complexity for a higher score. Had expected just a little more from this 2010 5th growth from Pauillac. — 5 years ago

The 2015 nose is so incredibly inviting and it totally follows through on the palette, bursting with berries. Superb accompaniment to carne asada steak or adamant pasta with red peppers and ewephoria cheese. — 6 years ago
Quite earthy on the palette with a nice long blackberry finish. — 7 years ago
Grilled pineapple on the nose, with soft peach, hint of almond and sea salinity. Crisp citrus on the palette but surprisingly soft with a rounded warmth to the finish. — 8 years ago
This is my last '06 and it has been awhile. Oh my, is this good! It is so balanced from front palette to the very very long finish. Complex and subtle simultaneously. It is a shame that I plowed through the first 5 early in its life cycle as this vintage clearly had decades of bottle life left. I have no control for outstanding wines. The good news is I have 3 '05s left (another delightful vintage) as well as others. — 9 years ago
Stunning and utterly singular. The nose is intensely mineral and almost impossible to categorize, with desiccated leaves, yellow fruit, green banana, plantain, wheat field, stones and crushed rock. The palate is opulent but incisive, with tremendous concentration, density and chew, almost carrying the structural energy of a red wine while remaining remarkably alive and fresh. The fruit is difficult to identify in any conventional way, which is part of the fascination, and the inner-mouth aromatics are thrilling. The finish is long, mineral and deeply resonant, with this uncanny honeycomb character, not honey itself, but almost the greatest ice-cream cone imaginable without the ice cream. Juicy, powerful, complex and beautiful in a way that feels unique in the world of wine. There is simply nothing else quite like Château Simone. — 2 months ago

It surprised me how fresh this still is! Youth is often wasted on the young but this wine managed to consciously show off with it at an age I would not have expected. It opens up considerably with air revealing a fresh fruity nose with notes of vanilla. The palette is rich, fruity and quite lengthy with grippy but ripe tannins. This wine remains one of the best values from Spain and it’s one of the best Aalto vintages I have ever tasted. 94+ — 5 years ago
This must have been quite an “in your face” wine when younger. This still has loads of fruit and sweet candy on the nose and palette. Soft tannins, some vanilla from the oak barrels. Nice balance! I guess this is in its sweet spot concerning drinking window. I am loving this a lot! — 7 years ago
Last bottle of Kumeu 😢. For now. So bright and refreshing, this is easily a summer Char. Gives White Burg and Central Cali quite a race, especially for QPR. Especially love the mid-palette citrus zest. — 8 years ago
When Anne-Marie tasted this, she was in raptures - @Martin G Rivard, thank you so much for this gem!
Huge extraction, ultra rich presentation. The nose is dominated with maraschino cherries, blueberry jam, and a whiff of talcum powder.
The palette is stunning. Dense and in-your-face. Tannins keep pumping. This exemplar presented so well. A head-spinner. Thanks so much, Martin!!! — 9 years ago

Big fruit and nice smooth finish but mid-palette was a bit flat. Got better with time. Hit the zone after a three hour decant — 9 years ago
Vanilla, oak and spices on the nose that beautifully integrates with tart cherry, blackberry and soft tannins on the palette. Very young wine that is of exceptional quality that would certainly benefit from aging to have tertiary flavors and aromas develop. — a year ago
2017 vintage for $55. Excellent red fruits and lush on the palette. Well balanced and not much p-funk or smoke flavors — 3 years ago
Okay, my natural bias on this wine is that it is generally over rated and over priced. Having said that, this vintage is very good. Reviews should be agnostic to price so I will do my best. This has an over abundance of black fruits jumping out of the glass. But it has enough acid to balance the fruit on the front and mid palette. The finish is shorter than you would like but overall balance between fruit, acid and tannins is very good. The bottom line is, if you asked me if I wanted you to open a ‘12 Caymus, I would say hell yes. Cheers! — 5 years ago
Bold yet elegant wine. Deep garnet in colour. Expressive bold tannins and high acidity. Blackberries, raisin, spice, tart cranberries and pepper on the palette. — 6 years ago
Loved this one. Silky smoothe palette with cherry & raspberry notes. Chewy tannins and a great long finish. — 9 years ago
Jason Gelman
2021 Simone blanc. nice drinking window. oily waxy savory. — a month ago