Lee Pitofsky

9.4

Hard to beat PYCM with the menu at Jônt. I love the Charmes site and 2014 is wide open, with just a touch of flinty reduction, but it’s all about its purity of yellow fruit that’s complimented by ripping citrusy acids, hazelnut and a hint of vanilla cream. Its supremely concentrated and dense palate shows great structure, power and a balanced stony minerality. This is still a baby but already evolving wonderfully. Great bottle. — 4 days ago

Kim Reisman McKee

9.0

Lemon and lees! Reductive at first and needed time to open up. Not too young which was a relief. High acid with medium body — 7 days ago

with Patrick

David Leiman

9.3

Acidic tart pear and apple balanced with pithy grapefruit and and insanely long finish — 25 days ago

Ricardo Bohn Goncalves

9.3

Mesa Bohn Corrutela Jun22 — 20 days ago

Mario Vaillancourt

9.1

Aromes de citron confit et fruits blancs, bouche qui se donne beaucoup, minérale, concentrée et tout de même fraîche, agec une longueur surprenante, très bien. 90-91

Gorgeous white, lemon, white fruit too, very giving palate, minerality and freshness, very good length. — 5 days ago

Andrew Schirmer

9.3

Day 1 like sucking on a cedar plank. Day two glorious fruit emerged. Fabulous texture. Serious shit. — 2 days ago

with Alsu and Geoff

Matt Perlman

8.9

Quite reductive—a bit clunky compared to the Chateniere — a month ago

Mario Vaillancourt

9.2

Le style de la maison est là avec cette minéralité et pierre à fusils, du fruit blanc aussi, intense en bouche mais avec de la finesse, une belle longueur, très très belle réussite. 92-93

Very PYCM in style, gun powder, minerality, salinity, gorgeous white fruit also, intense and with a nice rich texture but the acidity balances it out, very very good. — 10 days ago

Conrad Green

9.5

Wow. A punchy nose of citrus, marzipan, lifted lime. Resolved on the midpalate with great acidity. Delicious. — 12 days ago

with Chris, Jean-Francois and 2 others

Severn Goodwin

9.1

2018; A year later and some development, improvement on acidity & fruits seem more rich today.

(See prior notes) — a month ago