Daniel M

9.4

This is an accidental pour... I wanted to open one other Robert Weil erste lage Riesling trocken wine and didn't pay enough attention... well, this is probably much too young, but we like it anyway! The nose is slightly muted with lemon skin, a petroly thing, rose petals, elder flower, a touch of vanilla. Wow this is a bit unusual when compared to the usual german Riesling numbers I am used to. There is almost a tiny strawberry jogurt touch too. The palate is showing a great acid drive, some massive width, some grip all along, lemon zest, lemon juice, that same jogurty note all along... The finish starts with a massive, spherical, mid palate that powers up a real massive complex finish with lemon peel, strawberry jogurt that goes on for almost a minute. This is probably too young but this is a monster of a wine too. Hat's off! — 8 hours ago

romo

9.4

Entering third phase with acid firmly in tow. You’re inside an empty metal oil barrel. Perfection with non-key lime pie. — 2 months ago

Wolfgang Kaemmerer

9.2

What a Great Riesling from the Rheingau Region. Biodynamic, Perfect balance of fruit and minerality. His basic Riesling for an affordable Price — 5 months ago

Norman Gennaro

8.9

It’s got a lot of age on it so expected it to be a bit oxidized and it was. — 4 days ago

Peter Sultan

9.2

A mammoth, chiseled beast of a wine that really needs extensive decanting and/or aging. Despite a modest decant, imagine am tasting a tease of its true potential. — a month ago

with Owen

Tom Casagrande

9.2

This is the Trocken, not the Feinherb. Loads of stony minerality on the nose, to go with pristine apple fruit. Full and intense, nice acids. Quite dry but deep fruit. — 3 months ago

with Dan, Rebecca and 1 other

Jeroen Koenen

9.6

Bright shiny yellow in the glass. On the nose there is lemon-oil, grated ginger, cottoncandy and lovely earthy, funky notes of matchstick/flintstone reduction..!
Palate: creamy, soft acidity, lemoncurd, and powdery mineral nuances.
Gorgeous!!

— 22 days ago

Miyuki

9.1

Pale lemon in color. Off dry. Intensity of acacia, honeysuckle, grapefruit, lemon, lime, lychee, peach. Honey. Medium alcohol, medium body. Long finish. Balanced. Can drink now but potential for further aging. Outstanding. Alc. 11%. — 16 days ago

Raun Kupiec

9.0

Rich and dense, but not the petrol or chalk I was hoping for. — 4 months ago

Stuart Pollack

9.2

Nice sweet Riesling with a balanced acidity. Good with Chinese food. — 4 months ago