Joe DAscoli

9.4

Somewhat of a dessert wine and post dinner vino. This wine held up with great fruit and complexity. Really nice follow on to 25 year old CdP and high end champagne. Held its own with good concentration and depth. — 2 days ago

Vino Joe

9.5

Still has plenty of zip to go with the rich heft. Drinking well with a lengthy decant. — a month ago

Dan Tortora

8.9

Obviously too young but surprisingly approachable, great oaked nose — 14 days ago

WC Fields

9.0

Young. Nice to check in on these Horseshoes but I’ve learned they can go the distance. A few more years and this will unfurl. — 19 hours ago

Bruce Dunbar

9.2

A big wine in a big bottle that made a big group of friends very happy. The 2017 Evangelho Heritage (from magnum) is energetic with loads of sweet dark fruit. It doesn’t lack zing even though this year’s blend is short in Carignan — there are nice balancing acids and mild tannins. It is richer and riper than many vintages but still vibrant. — 23 days ago

Austin Hohnke

9.1

Almond butter. — 14 days ago

Andrew McIntyre

9.1

Impressive nose but lacking a bit of body at the moment. Too young and will no doubt improve in the coming 5 years. — 9 days ago

Jesse Fayne

9.2

Let her open up a bit. Rustic and medium bodied, earthy, just like a Umbria wine should taste — 14 days ago

Rashed Chowdhury

9.2

I love this wine. — 17 days ago

Conrad Green

9.4

Lucid and supple. Rounded fruit. Contained. Not too hot with lovely purity. Great stuff. A little tight. Some dried herbs. Delicious. — 22 days ago

with Rick