Matt Schwartz

9.6

Bright and racy. Lemon, lime, grapefruit and guava with the right amount of minerality. This is epic and for 6 years old it hasn’t lost a single step! Fantastic.

Update: After an hour the sea salt comes out. This really is a fabulous wine. — 4 days ago

Brad Jensen

9.6

Deep, dark ruby with a suuuper perfumed nose of ripe cherry and crunchy dark plum, with slightly bark notes and maybe even a little mint and balsamic showing in the background. Light medium bodied, with beautiful flavor and well integrated tannin, there’s still SO much energy to this, with strange and fun note of things like pine needles, balsamic, pomegranate, peppery notes and ripe plum, with hints of black mulch and iron integrated throughout. — 8 months ago

Jake Hajer

9.3

Funky, rich and smooth. Was feeling it. — 3 years ago

Ericsson

9.5

Such a savory wine! — 5 years ago

Jake Hajer

9.2

Aged very well. Rich fruit but with a shroud of macerated pepper, dense fruit but still an old world minerality. Very very good. — 5 years ago

Meg Herring

9.1

Incredibly crisp and dry with tons of minerality. — 7 years ago

Double Pound

9.5

Dyn-o-mite — 2 months ago

Randy Nielsen

9.0

71st birthday. The last bottle of Carignane… — 3 months ago

James K

9.2

Way too young. Needs time. Great potential. — 2 years ago

Jake Hajer

9.3

The Syrah adds such great mid palatte to the wine. Not enough cab/Syrah blends. — 3 years ago

Rebekah

9.3

Everything I want in a cab — 5 years ago

Jeff Orlowski

9.0

Floral and fruity nose. Medium body, dry, nice acidity. Quite nice. — 5 years ago

with Michael and Joe

Mirelsa Modestti

9.4

Stunning black fruit! We are drinking bottle number 585 out of 600. Feeling super privileged! Thank you so much, Marino Rodríguez. Time is priceless! — 8 years ago

Paul K

9.2

@Our Paladar @James K — 2 months ago

Aaron Forel

9.0

This Porter & Plot Cabernet is a straight 9.
Love it. — 5 months ago

Hunter

8.9

Very balanced, not dry. Would buy again — 3 years ago

James K

9.1

Big. New world meets old. — 3 years ago

Ericsson

9.5

Very elegant Bordeaux blend and as time dials down the alcohol and smoothes out the oak this will be a gem. — 5 years ago

Ross Fulton

9.0

Real FREAKIN’ naughty — 7 years ago

Keith Lite

9.1

Just enough oak and subtle fruit to make it really good — 8 years ago