Mark Mannebach

9.3

2010 vintage is perfect now. Still some dark red fruit wet stone minerality with a long finish — 3 hours ago

Michael Phillips

9.4

Sublime Chateauneuf du Pape.velvety smooth with luscious red and dark fruit. — 3 months ago

Timothy Eustis

Wine Director, Red Lion Inn

9.0

Brilliant. It’s faded and lost its way. But I love it. You won’t. Unless you understand what it’s like to have too old chenin that is of the highest caliber. Is it easy drinking? It’s not. Do I love it? I do. 2002 — 5 months ago

Matt Perlman

9.4

Somewhat riper than expected but still fresh and racy, crystalline acidity with tropical fruit, honeysuckle, bruised apple, petrol and cheese rind notes adding interest. And the color is stunning — a month ago

Martin Bergo

9.2

On magnum. — 4 months ago

Yan Gagnon

8.9

Rubis clair. Un nez de framboise et autres fruits compotés. Une bouche ronde, légèrement compotée, épicée et agréable. Simple, épicée. — 5 months ago

Pierre Gourinchas

9.2

Refreshing. Good structure. Delicious. — a month ago

Matthew Cohen

9.2

Nose: white flowers.

Palate: almost grunery. Wooly? Good fruit. Mineral. Well made.

Source — 2 months ago

Gregg G

9.2

Vibrant, racy, tight. Needs a yr or two but delicious after 2 hrs. — 4 months ago

Yan Gagnon

8.9

Robe dense. Un nez de violette, épices et des fruits rouges. Une bouche sur des épices (poivre - syrah) et des fruits rouges. L'alcool se fait trop sentir et ça brûle la gorge. C'est bon mais ça pourrait être meilleur si l'alcool ne piquant pas autant. — 5 months ago