Gilbert Van Hassel

9.4

Great combo but both a bit disappointing in their own way. Chambertin too much fruit not enough depth, Musigny quite light, great nose not followed by a great taste. Needs time to develop but still not meeting expectations. — 7 days ago

Stephanie Hui

8.9

Quite nice - fruity but not too jammy. Not sure I would have paid $45 for it though — 8 months ago

Carter White

9.0

Balanced and gluggable. — a month ago

Mike Evans

9.2

It needed a lot of air to start to show well. — 2 months ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.2

Nice nose of spice, mid season cherry, dark rustling leaves, wet moss, dark flowers, and lots of mineral. Terrific depth and ebullience on the nose. Palate is ripe and juicy but a bit one note, lacking in energy and the tannins seem a bit much for the vintage. Let’s see where this goes. The tannins melted away but it was boring and correct. — 11 days ago

Gilbert Van Hassel

9.6

Was the wine of the vintage and still going strong after 16 years. Beautiful garigue nose, blood sausage, licorice, very round. 3 bottles left. — 12 days ago

Timothy Eustis

Wine Director, Red Lion Inn

9.2

There are two kinds of st Joseph. This is one of the good ones. Long finish. Complex. Quite serious. — 2 months ago

Doug Powers

9.3

[80% Tannat, 20% Cabernet Sauvignon] Leather, forest floor, maybe a little Brett, excellent structure and depth, despite its age, seems like it can easily age another 10-15 years, long, lingering finish, excellent Madiran! — a month ago

with Jim

Jie Ling

9.0

Full bodied, rich. — 22 days ago

Ron Siegel

9.3

Youthful that is showing well. Consistent with my prior notes — 2 months ago