Spencer Fox

9.0

best value in germany, vintage after vintage. — 15 days ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.5

Merlot/Cab Sauv - floral, complex, soil based, lipstick like intensity, cassis, tobacco, pepper, pencil lead, chocolate, great intensity, freshness, energy, minerlaity, cassis, good structure. nose now gets so so good. cocoa, juicy and so good. — 5 months ago

UWS

9.2

2022.08.18: Schäfli Siebnen w/ Wakano
Chateaubriand wie immer
Wein immer noch gleich gut, hervorragend!
CHF 69? — 2 years ago

Robert Ahlstrom

9.0

Inky plum color, full bodied with cherries and plums, licorice, medium tannins. A big Napa cab that satisfies. — 2 months ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.3

Very mature. Opulent texture and needed maybe 15 minutes to get there. — 5 months ago

emilie cycz

10

Perfect acid and tropical fruits. Drank at room temperature. — 8 months ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.4

Another great vintage of a very overlooked Gutedel. Nose is superb. Lots of complex minerality. Herbs and subtle spice. Lanolin and a wonderful windy airiness. So pretty. Reminds me of a lean Jacquere from Savoie. Just killer. Smells like a scene in nature. Standing on a clearing in a forest overlooking a beach with the wind blowing the detritus. What a wonderful smell. Some peach skin if you really are looking for fruit. Chasselas in general has no fruit to speak of. Palate is wonderful. Big time structure and density with intense minerality and sap. Very fresh, very pure, with such a nice core of minerals. Like liquid rocks. Some herbs and some sort of umami flavor. This is so clean and so pure. Long finish. Like way longer than it should be. Easily best Gut&Edel I’ve had from Max. What a wine and what a finish. A true sum of its parts wine.

Acid gets more metal as this airs. Nose becomes more floral and also herbal. Truly wow. Almost a 9.5. So intense and tangy. Some intense high acid grapefruit confectionary goodness! — 3 years ago

Valerie Finley

9.5

This rose is amazing! Tastes like summer in a glass. Strawberries and apricots. Just lovely. Interesting as I haven’t had many German roses. So good!! — 5 months ago

Matthew Choi

9.4

Apricots, slightly feral — 6 months ago

Severn Goodwin

9.1

2017 | Red Blend
(Spätburgunder & Merlot; Rosé)
Max Geitlinger; Rosie
Rhine Valley; Baden, Germany
(90-92; drink 2023-27) — a year ago