Boris Mathiszik

9.3

A big cab for a big birthday. America 250 🇺🇸 with the last pre-acquisition vintage. — a month ago

Manrique

9.0

Costco, better than expected. — 8 months ago

M. Christopher Roebuck

9.2

Opaque purple in color, Welch's grape juice, cedar, and anise on the nose. Palate is evolved and settled with muddled blue and blackberry. Definitely nods to Porto with a tawny hint. A bit hot on the alcohol (guessing 14.8 ABV). Wine is dry, medium minus acidity. Full bodied. A bit of bitterness keeps this from presenting a rounded mouth feel. Tannins non existent at this point. Good.

92 points — 9 months ago

Vino Joe

9.5

Tropical fruit mixed with such harmony. Absolutely delicious. Very good to Superior vintage. — 4 years ago

George Chen

9.4

Superb mouth feel front to back...fruit, tabun, acid still in harmony and drank more like a old Burg...fabulous! — 6 years ago

Natassia

8.9

I shall be the first to rate the 2016 vintage.. I find this Chardonnay to be almost perfect. I am usually not a fan of chards but Trefethen has the talent to make it palatable for every drinker. It has a marshmallow touch to it, light golden color, apricot on the nose and slightly lemony on the back of the tongue and tingly at the very top. — 6 years ago

with nachobiz

Andrew

10

Light, nice sipping wine — 7 years ago

Dean Rogers

9.0

Excellent red blend! very tasty with Andrea and anniversary dinner!! — 2 months ago

Brian S

9.3

2023 vintage glad I have another bottle to see how this ages. Raspberry, cherry, plum, mushroom, forest floor, blood orange. Lovely wine. — 4 months ago

Damian Walch

9.5

Black currant, blackberry, and cherry, complemented by notes of chocolate, tobacco, spicy oak, and hints of lavender and graphite. On the palate, it is full-bodied and rich. Espresso, and spices. Great tannins and a long, persistent finish. — 9 months ago

Joe Carroll

Owner/Wine Director Spuyten Duyvil, Fette Sau, St. Anselm & Gotham Artisanal Provisions

9.2

A little softer and simpler than expected — 4 years ago

Alex Grenewitz

9.5

Great tasting with little heat and no aftertaste. Absolutely smooth, no ice needed. — 5 years ago

Cameron Parry

9.0

Wood got in the way of the fruit... otherwise totally solid. — 6 years ago

Matt

9.5

Drinking beautifully with a Northern appellation feel to it, more Brune and schistous to me. Would love to know all the lieu dits that contribute and their proportion in the final blend. Its darken fruit profile, meaty/smokey and forest notes make the argument that it’s of northern origin. Its opening up for now there’s a rich stream of dark black fruits reminiscent of Black raspberry liquor, soaked plums, almost prune, and overripe black berry/cherry. There’s still freshness to the fruit however, nothing ox’d or decaying. Singed cedar, leather, ash, roasted meat and animal come next, followed by the garrigue and bacon fat. Threads of eastern spices and of course pepper. It elusive now, the aromas coming and going. Palate has some lovely richness and bones to accompany it well, never pushy, always with restraint and nerve. Reminds me of Barolo. Great “basic” cuvée for Rostaing this vintage. Day 2 this really got going, much more harmony and focus on the nose. Loads of bitter root and pastille notes developing among its dark content. Very delicious — 6 years ago

Henry Fuseler

9.0

3/2026. Yes this wine has soul. Another great wine from the Davis Family. Nice full flavor and body Syrah. — 4 months ago

Nagib Nasr

9.0

Capping the night at a speakeasy in Bangalore India. Doesn’t get better than this. Amazing friends, great dreams, incredible memories! — 9 months ago

with Piers and Tripp

Alvaro Bustillos

9.5

Cena con winegeeks carloa gaytan — 2 years ago

Mike R

9.5

Heck yeah — 4 years ago

with Bill and David

Eric Urbani

9.2

This is a magnum of Jim Clendenen’s 2001 Harmony estate-bottled Chardonnay, “Nuits-Blanches Au Bouge” from the Santa Maria Valley in Santa Barbara County. Bien Nacido and Le Bon Climat vineyards. If you aren’t familiar with Jim or his Au Bon Climat and Clendenen Family labels, you are in for a treat. — 6 years ago

William Hicks

8.9

Good price but nothing special — 6 years ago