Edo Wachters

9.4

The Miani Friulano 2017 offers yellow fruits, apricot and ripe pear. It has tremendous length and freshness. A great wine. — 12 days ago

Andrew Cullimore

9.5

Medium ruby core , little more lighter garnet rim . Quite aromatic , spicy red plum , pine resin , red cherry and herbal , tobacco hints . On the palate a little richer and denser than the 2021 , herbal tinged red and dark fruits , pretty high acidity with more dusty tannins . Overall a bigger more structured tannic framed wine . Very long and powerful on the finish . Mineral and fresh summer fruit finish . This is very young still needs probably another decade , but is very promising . Balanced but powerful . Will probably have a longer life than the more refined and elegant 2021 — a month ago

Matthew Cohen

9.3

A beautiful wine.

Nose: white flowers. Lemon. Mountain meadow. A hint of sponti.

Palate: so clean. Drinking a mountain stream. Finely powders minerals. Lemon flowers.

More than the sum of its parts. It has an elegance.

This wine seems to oscillate between very dense meursault and a wispy chassagne like thing from vintage to another. A huge swing.

Fass selections — 3 months ago

Jeremy Shanker

Sommelier at RN74

9.3

Never had a bottle of Cialla that was too old. — 4 days ago

Rob Iracane

9.2

Barnyardy! — 22 days ago

Raun Kupiec

8.9

Nice complexity. Some lemon citrus but with a floral fruity base. — a month ago

Brit Young

9.2

Ripe fruits, medium+ body, just lovely. — 4 days ago

Jerry Clayton

9.4

Very nice and right. — 4 days ago

Ariel M

9.4

With Matan at יין בכרם נחלת בנימין — a month ago

Steve Rura

8.9

Peppery plum is really shining through on this one. Red licorice and dried spice accents. Tannic grape skin gives it some grip. Long raisin finish. Like the Sun-Maid boxes I ate as a kid. A little sweet for me, but still good quality. Also added some to the passata I’m making from heirloom tomatoes, and it’s quite nice. — 3 months ago