Electric! Wow what acid. Insane purity. Floral like nothing else. Kumquat, white flowers, tree bark, crushed rocks, mulch, lime zest, candied lemons, so complex, it’s crazy. Huge acid, huge depth, huge minerals, huge extract, so elegant, confectionary, pure, clean. So so so so good. Perfect, fruit, mineral, everything. — 6 years ago
Light, almond — 8 years ago
Exquisite. His top GG. Grown on decomposed granite. This is the only village in Baden on the slopes of the black forest focused on Rieslings. Dried apricots, meyer lemon, hint elderberry. Super elegant. Punchy acidity. For some reason I am less impressed than previously. — 3 months ago
Needs an hour of air. Becomes magnificent at that point.
N: white flowers and lemon floor wax. A hint of Passion fruit with air.
P: sweet lemon. Hint of apricot. Mineral. Laible brightness. Not as mineral as the Klingelberger. Very good density. Amazing deliciousness. Long. A great drink.
Fass selections — 7 months ago
Crisp and food friendly. I couldn't taste any influence of oak. — 7 years ago
Ok I want to marry this wine. For realz. Wish I had ten cases. Nose is so mineral it stung my sinuses. Palate is crunchy minerality. Some gorgeous lemon. Almost spicy. Long finish like you had a rock in your mouth. Wow. I hope I live to see another vintage where laible kills it like this. He just murdered it. Bought from fass selections. — 9 years ago

Such a serious Scheuerbe. Gorgeous nose. Wild herbs, sweet lime, sage, blackcurrants. High toned and so wild. Aromas in neon lights. Palate is slamming. Concentrated, elegant and densely structured but oh so nimble and super pure. Unreal class and finesse. So stunning and what a finish. Savory and alive. Cannot wait to see what air does. — 6 months ago

Astonishing how much acidity this has and how fresh it is. Unreal electricity from a so called low acid grape. Andreas Laible says this is a 25+ year wine. Insane structure. Unreal length. Superstar. Nose is pineapple, peach, some elegant VA but the palate is just insane. The quality is through the roof. It’s like 10% Rococo and 90% Laible. What a wine. — 7 months ago
Always needs age but I taste a sample every year for science! Stone fruits, apricot, spice, so complex. Really expressive for a young Am Buhl. Nuanced. Floral. Wow. I’m very impressed. Palate is stunning. Wow, what acid and freshness and concentrated like crazy stone fruits. Long, sappy and mineral. Really mineral. Huge, dense, grand Cru all the way. So much dry extract. Incredible amount of material here. More akin to Grand Cru Chablis than anything I’ve ever had from Germany. Stunningly long and expressive. — 7 years ago
More on the delicious end of the scale on open. Very fruity tangerine. Citrus. Awesomely mineral of course. Nice acidity. Lovely nose. As it opens becoming more serious. Rocky finish. ... fast forward 15 minutes. Ok ... now it’s liable. I’m chewing on rocks in a lemon vineyard. Best lemons ever. Sweet lemons with the acidity of regular lemons. Ok that makes no sense unless you are a lemon geek. Nose is insane. Gods lemon oil. Mad love. Bought from Fass Selections. — 8 years ago

Jon Tate
Beautiful Pinot! Drank with customers at Isidore in San Antonio. Favorite wine of the night! — 2 months ago