Conrad Green

9.4

Soft and pretty. Delicate rose edges with pretty bright plum fruit. Lucid and vivid. Very good — a day ago

with Chris, Tony and 2 others

Dave Mayers

9.5

Gorgeous! Rare vineyard. Took a day to open up. On the porch of Mugneret Gibourg. — 7 months ago

Conrad Green

9.6

soft red cherry. Really pretty roses petal edges. A whiff of Iodene and gorgeous lifted stuff. Really lovely and long. Subtle — 8 months ago

with BOT, Matt and 1 other

Jeremy Shanker

Sommelier at RN74

9.1

2019 Marechale held its own against 19 Mugneret Gibourg. Solid wine. — 2 years ago

Lee Pitofsky

9.6

“La Colombiere.” Pnp magic. Love the MG 19’s. It’s so obvious Vosne, wafting from the glass with a captivating perfume of red berries, rose petals and spices with an incredibly velvety palate. Just so giving and it was even better for lunch the next day! — a month ago

Ron Siegel

9.5

Surprisingly open with its beautiful fruit & spice. — 5 months ago

Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego

9.3

2020 vintage. Decanted. A bleep ton of color and concentration. Great now but would ideally like to give it 5-7 years to drop some of the overt fruitiness/focus and bring it into total harmony. 8.19.23. — 8 months ago

Lee Pitofsky

9.4

Love these wines. 2016 is a beautiful rendition, rich, spicy, and mineral, layered with oak framed vibrant fruit, sweet spices, violets and game, with a seductive, velvety and expansive palate with fine grained tannins. Drinking beautifully now but with a long life ahead. More Vosne than NSG which is just the way I like it. Last sips were the best. — 4 months ago

Conrad Green

9.5

probably a bit too soon for this. Salinity and a bit of black pepper. Powerful dark fruit and compact floral and stone notes. Great intensity but could probably do with some time to settle. Still elegant despite its youth this will likely be fantastic in a decade or so. Wonderful material here. — 8 months ago

with BOT, Matt and 1 other

Aaron Tan

9.4

Blinded, everyone agreed this was Burgundian but had their own ideas on village, vintage, and producer. No one figured out it was from Vosne - perhaps it just lacked the hallmark perfume and exoticism one might think of in Vosne (once more, the fallacy of generalisation in wine). MR was spot on with vintage though, and he was insistent about it due to that touch of austerity in the finish he typically finds in 08’s. As for producer, only MJ thought of Cathiard once the village was established. I was tossing between Mugneret-Gibourg (KP rebuts not sexy enough) and Meo (again KP rebuts not bright enough). What a tough blind by KP!

The wine itself was powerful and concentrated, with lots of mid-palate density, yet as MR observed, a tight finish. Flavours-wise, it featured heaps of red and black fruits (leaning more towards the latter) and some noticeable oak (though not decadent - nice quality!), as well as some earth and meat which probably threw me off in the blind. Having said that, the Vosne origin may have been linked to via the finish which had ample spice notes. A silky texture, lovely mineral undertow and tight acidity wraps up the wine. Really excellent wine but the pieces have yet to fall together to maximise drinkability. One to keep your hands off for now. — 2 years ago