Joe Weinberger

9.2

After having this a few times in the past month, I can confidently say this is my current favorite domestic Rosé. The price is right and it delivers a lot of pleasure each time. It can also age. This is the 2017 in magnum and it was singing after being open about an hour. — 4 years ago

Ming L

9.5

I still remember the first time I drank a Cristal, when a friend popped open a bottle (that he bought duty-free on a trans-Atlantic flight) at his SoHo apartment some 20+ years ago. Wasn’t much of a wine drinker then, but how wine could taste this good?!

Though from a lesser grand vintage, the 07’ did not disappoint. The purity of the fruits and chalky minerality are second to none. Crystal clear acidity provide great tension throughout. Graceful textured full body.

58/42 PN/Ch. Disgorged in 2015. — 4 years ago

Ron R

9.6

Disgracefully strong showing. Big and bold. Major explosion of fruit on the nose, and mid-palate. Soft brown sugar melds with broad-shouldered tannins. A knee-trembler for sure… — 4 years ago

with Cliff, Andrew and 1 other

Heather Danskin

9.6

Wow. A favorite white wine here. 52% Chenin Blanc 39% Viognier 9% Roussanne. So very delicious. Crisp, tart, floral, just the right balance. Very complex and interesting. YUM!! — 4 years ago

M. Christopher Roebuck

9.1

Over-oaked. I have experienced this with prior vintages of Quilt, so if you enjoy new wood dominant fruit forward Napa cabs, then this will be up your alley. Ripe and juicy. Nice medium plus body with high alc. A big wine. Screw cap closure so drink up sooner rather than later.

91 points — 4 years ago

Vasanth Balakrishnan

9.2

#vintagechampagne - the hype on 2012 Champagne is totally justified. Beautiful rosé sparkly here from Veuve: strawberry, rose hips, red apple on the nose, luscious fruit in the mouth with neat tension. What an experience! — 4 years ago

Gabriella Boros

9.5

Refined and bold and full of cherry and fruit right out of the bottle. Fabulous and big on the tongue. Lots of bold cherry and a bit of spice. Lovely linger on the tongue. Worked well with veg meal. — 4 years ago

Scott Soren

9.3

My first experience here. Lovely wine. It took some time to open, but the wait was worth it. A muted nose gave way to some florals and the palate is drive by blackberry jam, then some briny olive and peppercorn Really cool. Medium acidity and dark purple hue. Not a long finish but we’ll rounded and time will be it’s friend 93pts now, and i would guess it could reach 94-96 in time — 4 years ago

Adam Kincaid

9.2

$80 for this compared to $125 for Napa is a good deal, even if it doesn’t age as long. You’ll get your reward more quickly. I’m getting lots of twigs and wet bramble, cassis and mint. Medium bodied raspberry and super delish. — 4 years ago

with Jillian