Bob McDonald

9.6

Often the Grosset Polish Hill doesn’t live up to its billing as perhaps Australia’s finest dry Riesling but with this 2017 it probably exceeds expectations. It is simply fabulous. Some ripe lusciousness to the mid palate amid lime and lemon notes, but finishes bone dry. My first of 4 bottles so I will enjoy the journey over the next 5+ years if I can keep my hands off it. HH said it is shaping up as one of the greatest Polish Hill Rieslings. — 5 months ago

Kayla Buchanan

9.5

One of my favorites. Love this wine but can never find it anymore! — 5 years ago

Nick Piccone

9.0

Slightly sweet - could crush a full bottle easy — 6 years ago

Aaron Tan

9.3

KP likes to say that he makes pino for fun. However, if this wine is of any indication, KP's pino's are as serious as any of his rieslings. The 11' Burgel would easily give the Burgundies of the vintage a run for their money. In fact, it's apt to say that the wine was very Burgundian, given how most placed it in the region in our blind.

The wine's in a great spot for drinking at the moment. No greeness or lady bug. Bouquet of red and black cherries, sous bois, floral spice, mushroom, soy. The palate's energetic and tangy, fruit's a little more dried out with a more profound spice element, and a touch of creaminess. Silky texture, with tannins and oak fully resolved. There's a sort of balancing VA, which also brings savouriness - I feel this is what makes it quite Burgundian. Up for discussion of course.

It's good to see a pino from when KP still bottled them in riesling bottles - perhaps from when he still thought of them as "fun". This is the oldest pino that I've drank from Keller (would have been the 07' Burgel Felix last year if it wasn't corked. FU cork!) and I think it's safe to say he never did treat his pino's lightly. I mean, it's arguably even crazier now - we did spend four days just sorting the Morstein pino grapes, berry-by-berry, in 2017.

Unpopular opinion: KP's spatburgunder's are not value buys anymore (heck! The 2015 Morstein had a hammer price of 610€ in last year's VDP auction). For me, there's still better wines to be found in Burgundy at the prices that the Keller pino's go for. That said, with the rising prices of the latter, this opinion may soon be invalid. — 7 years ago

Devin Healey

9.0

Fuckkkkkkk I love Finger Lakes Dry Rieslings. cc @sammoman — 8 years ago

with Stephanie

Alan Cohn

9.0

Solid grass and honeysuckle notes — 9 years ago

with Harmony

Michael Ochsner

9.3

Beautiful and poised. S — 4 years ago

Marcio Morelli

9.1

Lu's Birthday
28/05/2022 at Metzi — 4 years ago

Chris Hailey

9.5

One of the best rieslings I’ve had. Big acid. Punches you in the mouth. Must buy! — 5 years ago

Makayda Malcolm

9.4

Has the basic aromas of your average Rieslings. This wine is off dry touching sweet. — 6 years ago

Chip Hughes

9.0

Always a notch above the pack of FLX dry Rieslings. Good concentration, fine texture and some complexity. Seamless and perfectly balanced, with essential Riesling fruitiness unmarred by reduction or by the crude, dark minerality that shale-heavy vineyards can sometimes convey. #flxriesling #wiemer — 7 years ago

Tom Casagrande

9.1

This bone-dry Riesling shows loads of green apple fruit, crushed rock, and some pleasantly, sponti-tinged, petrolly scents on the nose. Fresh, broad, and very minerally in the mouth, increasing as the finish goes on. Not for those who like fruity Rieslings, but very well done. — 8 years ago

with Lyle

Webb Bellow

9.2

Easily one of the best rieslings I've ever had. Finger lakes in a bottle. — 9 years ago

Arai Buendia

9.0

I don’t usually get German Rieslings because I have a hard time drinking a glass by itself. However when paired with spicy Chinese food, the wine is crisp and it’s hints of peach, help balance the plethora of spices. Refreshingly sweet on a hot day — 4 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.3

Kerosene aromas - some toast. Lovely mature Clare Valley Riesling. Palate has filled out with the influence of citrus diminishing and stone fruit increasing - under ripe peach. Nearly up to the standard of past Rieslings from the storied Florita Vineyard where legendary Rieslings were made for Leo Buring by John Vickery back in the 1970s. Next day strong citrus flavours - remarkably young for a 9 year old Riesling. Will go for at least another 6 years. — 5 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.0

Always good to see a screw cap on a European Riesling. Aromas of Pear, green Apple and Kiwi Fruit on nose and palate. The palate also has a creamy texture with a refreshing grapefruit twist at the end with Medium minus acid. Subtly different to German Dry Rieslings just over the border. A good time to drink and excellent value for money. — 6 years ago

Bob McDonald

9.2

Hot off the Press. Always one of Australia’s better Rieslings over decades. Dried white flowers on the nose. On the palate bracing citric acid with the tension you would expect from a young Riesling. A long life ahead as always. I still have a couple of the 2002 left. — 7 years ago

Reuben Smith

9.3

Enjoying a lovely older bottle. Definitely off dry but with all sorts of Rheingau flavours coming through. — 8 years ago

Matthew Cohen

9.7

The nose on this wine is magnificent. Words cannot describe. Gorgeously filigreed. A hint of aged Riesling. Palate has crystalline purity. Mineral. Gorgeously citrus. One of the best Rieslings I’ve ever had. Not overwhelmingly concentrated. But so balanced it’s damned near a work of art. Bought from Fass Selections. — 8 years ago

with Lyle

Hao Feng

9.0

Ripe, warm, dense, round, e/ honey, nutty aroma. — 9 years ago