Andrew Cullimore

9.0

Medium lemon colour , gold reflexes . Quite a lot of ripe yellow fruits , lemon rind and , orange flower . On the palate this is quite rich and round on the palate with yellow fruits, lemon rind , orange and almost some apricot or peach . Quite high alcohol but balanced acidity, good intensity , quite dense though just balanced overall. Would have preferred a little less weight and a bit more freshness . Alright length . This is ready now , but will probably last another 3-5 years but I wouldn’t leave it too long. — 10 days ago

Stan Nguyen

9.3

Slight fizz from Malo. Light and juicy. Really great — a month ago

Ron Siegel

9.3

Slight reductive note that quickly blew off with notes of orchid fruits, wet stone, chalk & floral tones — 2 months ago

Rob Krapf

9.2

Citrus and apple with a crisp finish  — 11 hours ago

with Tom

Jay Kline

9.6

The 2022 “Sous Roche Dumay” pours a straw color with medium viscosity. On the nose, the wine is developing with remarkable notes of bright tropical and ripe orchard fruit, a lovely mix of yellow and white flowers and laden with chalky minerals. On the palate, the wine is dry with medium+ acid. Be still, my beating heart…the acid! Confirming the notes from the nose. The finish is long and delivers a serious dose of the minerals, keeping up with the two Raveneau enjoyed alongside. Brilliant. This was arguably the best of the three paired with the pôchouse bourguignon but really, all three worked well. Drink now through 2052. Thanks for the assist @Lyle Fass — a month ago

Brendan Baker

9.1

Lemon, matchstick reduction, Granny Smith apple, med acid ✨ — 2 months ago

Rob Krapf

9.5

Elevated minerality balanced with a pleasurable smoothness. The perfect 3rd bottle. — 10 hours ago

with Tom

Rob Krapf

9.5

Good minerality, clean and crisp with bold oomph — 11 hours ago

with Tom

Tyler Felous

10

Just perfect. — a month ago

Ron Siegel

9.3

This was showing well with Lemon curd, orchid fruit, silky, balanced mouthfeel on the palate, mineral & floral notes — 3 months ago