Marginy Carbonic Pinot Noir

Domaine Bechtold

Obere Hund Pinot Noir 2009

Shay A
9.1

I’ve been wondering when to open this wine, and when a local group decided to do a Pinot theme blind, I thought this would be a fun contender.

My second time with this wine in the last year, and I remain impressed at how this 13yr old Alsatian Pinot is holding up. Translucent ruby in the glass. Doesn’t seem to show much bricking, actually. Aromatically, it’s bretty…smells more Bordeaux like than anything else. Leather, herbs de Provence, underripe black cherries. The palate shows a small bit of carbonic character (not with the bubble gum vibe, but more of that cru bojo wintergreen profile). The fruit shows a faded/muddled profile due to the age, but there is plenty of dirty raspberry, black cherry and a savory red clay like note. Good acidity still. While this is on the downside, I’m hard pressed to say this is way over the hill. It’s actually a really fun and delicious wine to enjoy over an evening (especially with food).
— 2 years ago

Tom, Joshua and 22 others liked this

St. Reginald Parish

The Marigny Carbonic Maceration Willamette Valley Pinot Noir

Vinegar/cider start, good with salty snacks and fried rice — 4 years ago

David Anderson
with David

BK Wines

Carbonic Lenswood Pinot Noir 2019

Action packed for a pinot will go there again! Great price point too — 5 years ago

Scott liked this

Cameron Winery

Abbey Ridge Pinot Noir 2019

Gor
9.2

Signs of cemi carbonic maceration tastes like a cru beajolais with an extra layer of complexity. Black pepper, red currant, cherries, roses. Cool stuff. — 2 years ago

Domaine Duroche

Gevrey-Chambertin Pinot Noir 2017

Red fruit. Damp earth. A touch carbonic. First Duroche. Style reminds me of Fourrier. — 3 years ago

Pooneet, Ira and 1 other liked this

By Farr

Farrside Pinot Noir 2018

Jaz
9.2

Bunchy, rich earthy nose some carbonic — 4 years ago

Arterberry Maresh

Dundee Hills Pinot Noir 2012

In the past, this wine has screamed watermelon jolly rancher, almost like it undergoes carbonic maceration. My last btl was about 4 years ago, and things are different now. The waternelon jolly rancher note is still there, but it is enveloped in an earthy complexity, with floral notes. On the palate, excellent acidity, great red currant and wild strawberry, mediun to light bodied, attenuated tannin on a crisp, but clean finish. At peak, imo. — 5 years ago

Marc, Severn and 1 other liked this

Gérard Raphet

Les Grands Champs Cuvée Unique Bourgogne Pinot Noir 2019

Hands down the best Bourgogne I’ve had. Pure juicy fruit, semi-carbonic aromas, cinnamon sticks, wet slate ….lip smacking. Drinks akin to a passé-tout-grain. Beats out Leroy, and many many others. 🤯 — 3 years ago

Chris, Romain and 3 others liked this

Sandhi Vintners

Amrita Arroyo Grande Valley Pinot Noir 2017

Wine geek Pinot. Own rooted, carbonic maceration, no sulphur, magnum. Personally I’d love to taste this with traditional fermentation. The fruity crunchiness almost gets in the way; yet that’s what it’s supposed to be. I’m asking for inauthenticity. For what this is, the expression is incredibly pure, nose to tail. — 3 years ago

Brian, Bryan and 8 others liked this

Domaine Philippe Tessier

Cheverny Pinot Noir Blend 2019

Nate Wall
9.2

Carbonic character is really kickin here. Beaujolais, but with more richness across the mid-palate. Bursting with ripe berry fruit, even a hint of blueberry which is cool. Started eating kalamata olives with it and it took the fruit to another level. Added a savoriness that it may have been lacking and just pushed it up a notch. Like the style, a well-made wine. — 4 years ago