Eliot Hamerman

9.0

Drinking nice, NV — a month ago

Andrew Schirmer

9.3

Blanc des noirs. Angular. Terrific aromatics. Mousse is on point. Light brioche, cider notes. Mineral finish. The aromatics stay with you. Cool project from the Vouette & Sorbée folks with some neighbors’ fruit. — 3 years ago

with Alsu

Johan Jepson

9.3

Deg: 11/2016 — 5 years ago

Doctor No

9.3

Complicated. Subtle VA and oxidative notes. Lemon juice reduction drizzled over brioche. A bit aggressive and good with aggressive food. Lacks a bit of the midpalate. — 7 years ago

Gregg G

9.2

From magnum. Shows a very light salmon-copper hue. Very tight and reticent on first pour with some lemony citrus notes. With an hour of bottle decant, it’s generously showing red berry fruits, hint of butterscotch and oven fresh croissant. Beautifully long with a wonderful richness for a no dosage. Why is champagne always better from magnum? — 5 months ago

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.4

Now we are getting into the serious cuvees at Robin and this is a doozy. What a nose. Insane lime. It’s so so vivid. Green apple skin. Superb minerality and expansiveness. Gorgeous clarity. Really firing on all cylinders. Much more of what I look for. Cheap champagne can be good but I prefer mid range and high end for drinking and selling. Candied but in a super rocky way. The most clear minerality you can imagine. 9.5 nose. What a palate. It’s crazy. I never had anything like it. It’s got a crazy attack and then this elite finesse than low tide waves crashing for 45 seconds finish with superb finesse. It’s crazy wow. Great mouthfeel and wowza acids and freshness. Concentrated but not too much and never heavy. So floats on the palate but has serious structure. Hits you in the molars and stays there. This wine changes like crazy in 10-15 minutes. It’s a total think piece champagne and it’s so unique. Super geeked and super delicious. Bravo. The Sorbee, indeed, does have a secret. Textured and so juicy with such a great three acts. — 4 years ago

Neil Cornish

9.2

Beautiful balance. Very elegant. Nutty and smooth. — 6 years ago

with Jon, Michael and 1 other

Brendan Baker

9.2

Deep salmon with hints of orange, cherry and earth, some tannic grip. R12 disgorged 26/11/14 😜 — 8 months ago

Mike Levin

9.4

Disgorged: 3/7/17. Lots of life and depth with light oxidative flavors and precise quince. More bubbles going here than in the 2006. — 5 years ago

Raj Harb

9.4

A bit fuller and rounder following the vouette. But also delicious. Purity of the fruit comes through. — 6 years ago