Sibling Rivalry

Bodegas Benjamin de Rothschild-Vega Sicilia

Macán Clásico Rioja Tempranillo 2019

Ming L
9.2

The Clásico is quite new world in style, just like the Macán, its senior sibling. It’s more concentrated and has a bit more depth than the 18’ Macán, a testament to the excellent 19’ vintage in Rioja. — a month ago

Douglas, Somm and 3 others liked this
Somm David T

Somm David T Influencer Badge

Nice buy! Cheers! 🍷
Ming L

Ming L

Thanks @David T !

R. López de Heredia

Viña Bosconia Reserva Rioja Tempranillo Blend 2007

Tasted alongside the Tondonia, the 2007 Viña Bosconia has a near identical profile, and as such it’s very hard to differentiate between the two. After several hours’ air - this took far longer to open up than the Tondonia - it shows generous aromas of dried cherry, blackberry and a green herbal edge that wasn’t a feature of its sibling.

Hard to pick a winner now between the two, but I feel in ten years the Bosconia will have the edge.
— 3 years ago

Josh, Keith and 1 other liked this

Fillaboa

Rías Baixas Albariño

Good value. Grapey with aroma. Possibly better value than premium sibling — 4 years ago

Domaine Jean-Michel Gaunoux

Clos des Chênes Volnay 1er Cru Pinot Noir 2017

2017 vintage. Punchy and unconsolidated like a younger sibling. Plenty of moments of great height afoot. Medium-heavy body. Not as well knit as I'd like given the year/age and da money. Flighty here, tangents there. Still, tasting the wine, the pedigree and quality are evident. 01.04.25. — 4 months ago

Severn, Daniel and 10 others liked this

Xavier Vignon

Cuvée Anonyme Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend 2017

Well, we were going to have a party for the senses tonight, so why not have a little vertical tasting. After the excellent 2012 that was so expressive and rich, we turned to the 2017. Wow, much tighter and a strong kick into the shins with vibrant spice. Again, young red flavors of red berries and tangy raspberries drenched in white pepper spice. It did open up more and revealed more of earthy under notes but remained much more single dimensional than its older complex sibling who will be ingrained in our memories for along time. — 3 years ago

Gert-Jan Tammy de Weerd
with Gert-Jan and Tammy
Skip, Ericsson and 4 others liked this

Domaine Roulot

Bourgogne Blanc Chardonnay 2017

Sibling rivalry. Domaine vs Jean-Marc. Domaine more Meursault, Jean-Marc more exotic and lively. Both are killer — 4 years ago

Au Bon Climat

Santa Barbara County Pinot Noir 2018

C J
9.0

The younger sibling of one of my favorite value wines (la bauges), this is much fruitier with a bit less finesse and depth. Loads of strawberries. Still good value. Will probably improve for many years. — 4 years ago

DL
with DL

L'Aventure

The Sibling Willow Creek District Red Blend 2022

Beautiful color and well balanced. Long delicious finish — 5 months ago

Andrew, Shay and 4 others liked this

Grosset

Springvale Clare Valley Riesling 2013

Lemon in colour. See previous Delectable note. Paraffin notes developing. On the palate Barb thought white nectarine notes. Crisp and clean - a beautiful mature Riesling. My last bottle but it could have been left a few more years. Having said that it is hard to see it improving over the standard it is now. An earlier developing style than its sibling Cuvée, Polish Hill. — 2 years ago

Ira, Ron and 26 others liked this
Bob McDonald

Bob McDonald Influencer Badge

@Ira Schwartz Haven’t had the 2010. Had the 2012 a year ago and found it a little austere. Could go another year or two? Notes here on Delectable.
ESF

ESF

I’m still holding 04
Bob McDonald

Bob McDonald Influencer Badge

Good on you ESF. I’m sure they will go the distance.

Peay Vineyards

Estate Scallop Shelf Sonoma Coast Pinot Noir 2012

Beautiful, elegant, lighter sibling for Pomarium. Pairing with takeout Peay-king Duck from Great China to celebrate. — 4 years ago