Norman Gennaro

9.5

From mag. Needs air and then sings. — 5 days ago

Brian S

9.5

Blue and red fruit, well integrated tannins and acidity, bay leaf, cocoa, Tabasco leaf, barrel spice, black rock. — a month ago

Bryan Florendo

9.0

Not Lina’s fave. — 2 months ago

Howard Greenfield

9.6

2017 kicking ass — 3 months ago

Joe Flo

9.7

I just think Carter’s 🍷 are awesome. I just wished there bottles were smaller. 2019 still needs decanting for several hrs. — 20 days ago

Bill Morgan

9.6

Dark fruit now with leather tones. Smooth and complex — a month ago

Kurt Schuster

9.3

 Absolutely loved the detail on the bottle. Had this with some very fatty ribeyes and just absolutely hit it out of the park. A deep nose it almost comes off. Still hot with alcohol, but dry forest floor and rich garrique scents. Very bold and rich with ripe bursting plum, Rosemary, thyme, and butter, definitely enough structure to hold up against a good thick steak. Can’t believe this thing is 11 years old and still kicking it.  — 3 months ago

with Denise

Joe Flo

9.7

4 hr decant very helpful. — 20 days ago

Brian S

9.6

Pretty nose of rose and violets, soft blue and red fruits, touch of cocoa, hint of fresh herbs, velvet in the mouth, smooth and lively grippy tannins that makes you want to go back for more, black rock and soil. — a month ago

Steve Somermeyer

9.2

Really hanging in there for. 15 yr old Cab. Fruit is still there will soft tannins. — 3 months ago