Richard Rosensweig

9.6

What a beauty! Black cherry, plum, licorice, a bit of spice. Long, long, looooong finish. So balanced with structure, but mellow as well. Sublime. — 6 days ago

Scott@Mister A’s-San Diego

9.3

2018 vintage. Medium body. Bunches of ripe, dark fruit in the flavors framed by spiciness and earth. Youthful and could use a half-decade to settle down/integrate just a bit. Pretty nice now tho. 3.27.24. — 9 months ago

M. Christopher Roebuck

9.1

Siena...

So this really never mellowed. Stayed pretty hot.. I think this could sit a while longer. Hopeful but when I drink a 2012 Ciacci Piccolomini, it's ready. So I don't know.

91 points — 7 years ago

Jean Kim

9.5

Better with each hour especially at hour 4. — 23 days ago

Tim Eller

9.5

Big, jammy old world goodness, with mild tannins and a finish that echoes relentlessly around in the mouth. Mild spice box and wafts of dried leaves subtly compliment the whole package. Magnificent. — 8 months ago

Kai Wright

8.9

A little help turning that Tuesday corner. Indulgently flavored bang for the buck here. Boozy, but intense dark fruits and mature tannins with a nice long finish. — 7 years ago

speedy duncan

9.1

Stunning how this came around with air and baby backs cole slaw and spud salad for the love of labor — 7 years ago

Rob N

9.3

I love this Montalcino ($63 Davidson’s) and the general cherry-herbal-menthol flavor profile of Montalcinos. I’ve had this one before, and enjoyed just as much. The highest Delectable rated of my recent Montalcino purchases, interestingly. — 4 months ago

Anthony Ludwig

9.2

Vito’s Pizzeria — 2 years ago

M. Christopher Roebuck

9.3

Opened this last night, poured into decanter To around midnight, fell asleep, woke up a 4 am and said "shit, my Tenuta!" Covered decanter with plastic wrap. And now, 20 hours later, it's smooth...

93+ points

It's shy of the Ciacci Piccolomini Pianrosso, and I actually give a nod to the non-reserva version (see prior rating). — 7 years ago