Arnyca Cellars

Fulldraw Vineyard

Paso Robles Rosé Blend 2017

Shay A
9.3

One of the best rosés I’ve had in quite some time. 66% Grenache, 34% Mourvèdre. Bigger style with lots of complexity and depth to it. It’s as though someone took two of my favorite rosés, Arnyca (lighter style) and Antica Terra (super heavy style) and combined them. In the glass it has an absolutely gorgeous deep ruby color. Aromatically, it has spicy red fruits like rhubarb with watermelon, peppercorn and sea salt. It tastes remarkably like a gummy version of rhubarb, showing more spice at the finish. Not made in the crushable style, this deserves and commands some thought (and food)! My thanks to @Bill Bender for the wine and introducing me to the potential of this producer. — 7 years ago

P, Eric and 44 others liked this
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@P A : Cheers to you, and I hope 2020 is wonderful for you and yours!

@Jake Rubash : I’m sold on this for sure. I need to try their other wines.

@Deborah M : If you enjoy the bigger style rosés, you will love this. Best at cellar temp, almost treating it like a light bodied red!
Bill Bender

Bill Bender Influencer Badge Premium Badge

I’m stoked you liked it as much as me @Shay A the props go to @Connor McMahon I’m pretty confident you’ll dig his big polished reds as well
P A

P A

@Bill Bender Bill From Canada Happy New Year Cheers 🥂

William Harrison Vineyards & Winery

Rutherford Cabernet Franc 2014

Shay A
9.3

@Mark Flesher and I did a quick side by side tasting of two 2014 Napa Valley Cab francs tonight and it’s always such a joy to try wines side by side that are the same in one respect, but can differ so greatly!

I opened a bottle of ‘14 Arnyca Cab Franc (I’ve posted a few times, so no need for me to be redundant, but it’s a killer bottle of Cab Franc) while Mark opened this. At pop and pour (and throughout the hour) where the Arnyca was lush and approachable, this had a volcanic type back end note and was very tannic. The fruit was still there, but it was a bit more complex due to the earthy type note. This continued on the palate with a more spicy/peppercorn finish. Changed in the glass quite a bit. This has all the stuffing of a great cab franc (fruit notes of rhubarb, blackberries, and plum, cherry spice, and an herbal/earthy finish) as well as structure and age ability. This is without a doubt the best sub $60 Cab Franc I’ve ever had. 9.3 score, but 9.4 would have happened with more air. Expect this to be 9.5 with 5-7 yrs of age.
— 9 years ago

Mark Flesher
with Mark
Mark, Ryan and 29 others liked this
Stephen Jackshaw

Stephen Jackshaw

@Paul Treadway Huntington Beacher the vineyard 29 Franc is outstanding. I have notes from last few vintages, never skip those offers.
Stephen Jackshaw

Stephen Jackshaw

The ‘14 is still very tight, I accidentally opened one on Christmas
Mark Flesher

Mark Flesher

Agreed Stephen. I think the 10's and 11's are drinking best right now.

Favia

Cerro Sur Napa Valley Red Blend 2013

Shay A
9.5

Steve, the owner of Arnyca, took us to Torc after our tasting for dinner. He had the chef bring out a custom menu which meant the chef sent out whatever the chef was feeling. I am STUFFED. Steve opened his ‘13 Arnyca alongside a surprise bottle, and this ended up being the comparison.

For what it’s worth, this was a tough choice blind. The table ended up favoring the Arnyca ‘13 over this (the Favia ‘13 is a 98 pointer), but I suspect this Favia will long outlive the Arnyca. It’s also double the price. If you love Cab Franc, buy both to compare. They share similar dark fruit notes of black cherry and currant, but differ after that. Favia has more blue fruit while the Arnyca has more red fruit and herbs. Arnyca is 100% Cab Franc, while Favia is 80-85% Cab Franc. Big difference.
— 9 years ago

Eric, Eric and 42 others liked this

Dendinora

Arnyca Rosé Blend 2016

Shay A
9.3

I keep going back and forth between Montagu's rosé and this, but the most recent head to head goes to Arnyca. Arnyca, who has my favorite cab franc, just released this for their first rosé...what a start!

Great balance between tart fruit (raspberries, rhubarb) and sweet fruit (peach, pineapple, kiwi). Very aromatic. Crisp acidity from start to finish...the finish has a "soft" feel, as though you're tasting the skin of the fruit on the inside of your cheeks, and then drops off with a granite/crushed rock note. I'll be buying this rosé every year 👌
— 9 years ago

P, Severn and 21 others liked this
P A

P A

@Shay Aldriedge Love your dog 🐶
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Thanks @philip Angino ! That is Indie. She has a sister, Abbie, that we also have and she is also covered in spots...but taller and more lean!
P A

P A

@Shay Aldriedge She looks like a great dog and companion. We love dogs up here

O'Brien Estate

Passion of the Soul Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2013

Shay A
9.4

Ok. I know this is O'Brien, and they have great wines. This specific cab, along with the rest of the OBrien line up was impressive. But. Winemaker Mark's private label, Cobden Wini, and Steve Distler's label Arnyca, were the standouts. The Cobden Wini late Harvest Sauv Blanc and the Arnyca Cab Franc were some of the best from this trip. Ordered over 2 cases between the 6 of us. The experience at O'Brien was so cool...feel like it was done by guys that I'd like to grab beers with and hangout with on a Tuesday night. If you visit Napa, stop by here! — 10 years ago

David, Jason and 27 others liked this
Mark Flesher

Mark Flesher

@Shay Aldriedge I still believe the best Napa CF I've had was a 2008 Crocker and Starr. Maybe it was the company I was with, or just that the wine was singing more than usual that night. If Eppler brings his Franc to the tasting as he is notorious for doing, I want to know what you think of that one too.
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Mark Flesher : I keep hearing all about Crocker & Starr. Need to try it. Hope to try quite a bit at the event on Wednesday!

ARNYCA Cellars

Cabernet Sauvignon 2016

Greg Ballington
9.4

Absolutely lit 🔥. Love this new wine Steve!

Deep purplish ruby red. A bit tight to start on the nose but increases in intensity with air. Dark and spiced nose with dark cocoa, licorice, graphite, toasted oak influence and blackberries. Medium plus tannins (7.5/10) with a full body. Great backbone coated with black and bramble berries, powdered cocoa, pencil shavings and baking spices. Long finish. Drink till 2040. (94+)
— 7 years ago

Sean BallingtonIndia Okoh
with Sean and India
Clive, Paul and 16 others liked this

Marchesi Mazzei

Siepi Castello di Fonterutoli Toscana Super Tuscan Blend 2011

Greg Ballington
9.4

One of the extra bottles from the Jack Winery and ARNYCA Cellars tasting last night with Steve Distler.

Deep purplish red with ruby edges. Well balanced nose with layers of earth, red currants, tobacco, damp earth and a touch floral. Medium dry tannins (6/10) with a medium plus body. Quite a bit of acidity with bramble, black currants, cherries and earthiness. Long finish. Drink till 2024.
— 8 years ago

David LSean BallingtonIndia Okoh
with David, Sean and 1 other
David, Stef and 28 others liked this

Crocker & Starr

St. Helena Cabernet Franc 2015

Shay A
9.4

What an incredible second day here in Napa. Jesus started us off with an amazing tasting at Davies/Schramsberg, Crocker & Starr gave us our cab franc fix, Montagu & Addax put on a double tasting, and Hourglass knocked it out of the park at the end of the day! I won’t post each wine we tasted, but I’ll highlight the best from each spot.

We are all die hard Cab Franc fans, so a stop here was a must after
@Carl Fischer introduced me to this cab franc last year. First, the property itself is flat out gorgeous. Quaint and quiet. Awesome history here as well.

This cab franc is a BABY. New release. Red and black fruits are still fighting to take over...didn’t get much blueberry off of this like I did the ‘12, but age plays a part. Violet, lavender, black truffle and a touch of spice. A benchmark for Napa Cab Franc, alongside Arnyca and Detert. The Post 1 bottle is their current release (2013) Cabernet that is their purest expression of Cabernet from the Estate. This is serious Cabernet...tannic, structured and could compete with top end mountain wines.
— 9 years ago

Jason, Weijie and 25 others liked this
Stephen Jackshaw

Stephen Jackshaw

@Shay A that makes sense. Although in all honesty I like their standard Cabernet aged typically five to seven years before starting to open them. They are graceful agers!
Carl Fischer

Carl Fischer Influencer Badge

Stellar line up!!! Haven’t even heard of the Post 1. Looks like you’re having a great trip @Shay A enjoy!!
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Carl Fischer : Post 1 is brand new to C&S and is their version of top end, most pure expression of Cabernet. Keep hands off for many years...enjoy the cab franc 😍

Gargiulo Vineyards

Money Road Ranch Rosato di Sangiovese Sangiovese 2016

Shay A
9.3

After my first sip, my words were “I wish I had more of this.” Holy smokes. This is hands down one of the best rosés I’ve had out of Cali (alongside the Arnyca rosé). The acidity is so sharp out of the bottle. Love that! So many rosés are flabby and creamy. Kiwi and strawberry in the nose. Watermelon, cantaloupe, and plum skin on the finish. This is the epitome of refreshing rosé. I need to give credit to @Shawn R for gifting me this bottle from when we were together at his house a few months ago. Loved it, brother! Perfect by the fire pit. 👌 — 9 years ago

P, Ryan and 33 others liked this
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Jason Brater : I’d highly recommend trying it if you come across it. Rosé of Sangiovese isn’t common, and this is flat out awesome.
Bill Bender

Bill Bender Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Watch yourself @Shay Aldriedge when you accept “gifts” from @Shawn R I’m still dealing with a lot of regret and shame after he requested and received payback 😞
Shawn R

Shawn R Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Keywords being “received payback”. Meaning you wanted to return the favor! That’s the part he can’t help!

Detert Family Vineyards

Oakville Cabernet Franc 2012

Shay A
9.5

When @Carl Fischer and I did our cab franc swap, we sent a few solid Cab francs and other misc wine, but the main reason for the swap was trading our favorite cab franc...for me, the Arnyca, and for Carl, the Detert. After finally opening this up, I can see what all the hype is about. This is pure, big boy cab franc. Deep royal purple in the glass. Although Carl recommended a decant, I wanted a small taste at pop and pour...hey-o! This sucker flexed its muscles, punched me in the face, and said "you'll wait". At about an hour and a half in the decanter, this opened BEAUTIFULLY. Violet, blackberry pie, sweet tobacco on the nose. Great acidity and mouthfeel. Chewy blackberries on the palate. This beaut of a cab franc will age so nicely. Oh man, I need to try one of these at about the 7-10yr mark. Bravo, @Carl Fischer ! You made me a believer (and my fellow cork monkey in the pic). — 10 years ago

Jason, Brandon and 36 others liked this
Jeff D.

Jeff D. Influencer Badge

@Carl Fischer the Moulds Vineyard and Atlas are also exceptional!!
Carl Fischer

Carl Fischer Influencer Badge

@Jeff D. - have not tried the Atlas but love the Moulds. They also have a really nice Sauv Blanc.
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Carl Fischer : FYI, this Detert is making swoon on day 2! So freaking good!

Diamond Terrace

Premiere Napa Valley Auction No. 13 Lot No. 82 Two Mountains Cabernet Sauvignon 2007

Greg Ballington
9.3

Another wine from our ARNYCA Cellars and Jack Winery with Steve Distler. Bottle number 8 of 60.

Medium to deep ruby red. Layered nose with truffles, woody, a bit stinky, black cherries and earthiness. Medium plus dry tannins (6.5/10) with a medium plus body. A little vegetal and earthy on the palate with dark red fruits coming through. Well rounded with acidity holding up. Long and lingering finish. Drink till 2027.
— 8 years ago

Sean BallingtonIndia OkohDavid L
with Sean, India and 1 other
David, Shay and 35 others liked this
David L

David L Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Greg Ballington Thank you again for the invite last night. We had such a good time.
9.1

Dendinora

Arnyca Howell Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon 2016

Shay A
9.4

@Delectable Wine : This is the Arnyca Cabernet Sauvignon. It’s a brand new wine (still in the shiner!), so I didn’t find it in the database.

Day 1 of Napa in the books!

My affection for Arnyca’s CabFranc is well documented, and in 2016, they had the chance to make some CabSauv from Howell Mtn. Even at this age, after 30-45mins in the decanter, it really mellowed out and was plush. Dark, baked fruits, chocolate, graphite, sweet toasted oak. The aromatics had a very pronounced smoked cedar and fig note. Very accessible for a ‘16 Howell Mtn Cabernet, & extremely smooth. Lots of potential here. Excited to see how it evolves.
— 8 years ago

Ted, Rob and 28 others liked this

Château d'Yquem

Sauternes Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend 1998

Shay A
9.7

A “thank you” from Steve of Arnyca after dinner. Holy smokes, this was like drinking liquid honey. So much texture and weight. Honeyed almond, dried apricot, and molasses. My first D’Yquem. Hope to find an ‘88 for my 30th later this year. — 9 years ago

Eric, Eric and 43 others liked this
Mark Flesher

Mark Flesher

Liquid honey indeed! It's been a long time since I have had Yquem.... it was definitely pre tasting notes. What an awesome gift and surprise!
JJ Lumia

JJ Lumia

Wow this is amazing

Dendinora

Arnyca Napa Valley Cabernet Franc 2013

Everything I love in a Cab Franc. Minty modern palate with big fresh fruit and no green. Great call @Shay Aldriedge - thanks for the swap! 2 hr decant. — 9 years ago

Jason, Joe and 17 others liked this
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

So glad you enjoyed @Eric S ! I’m with you...everything I love in a cab franc! I brought your Tenor Syrah home yesterday to open up on Monday...stoked to try!
David L

David L Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Very enjoyable

Jack Winery

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2014

Shay A
9.4

Steve Distler, owner of Arnyca, is doing consulting for a few small labels out in Napa. As I've posted before, his Arnyca cab franc is my favorite out of Napa Valley. He was the former GM at O'Brien Estate and was able to add them to his portfolio, along with Cobden Wini (winemaker for Arnyca and winemaker at O'Brien), Frias Family and Jack Winery. Killer line-up of small production stuff. We hosted him for a wine dinner and all of it was stellar.

Jack Winery utilizes the talents of Aonair winemaker Grant Long Jr. Jack was started by Vernon Wells (former MLB player) and Chris Ianetta (current MLB player). This '14 cab is from Diamond mountain and drinking well at a young age. Not as monstrous as young Howell Mountain cabs. Red and black fruit dominant with a decent amount of espresso and pepper. Needs to rest for a few years but has very good potential to be extremely good.
— 10 years ago

Steve Distler
with Steve
Steve, Greg and 45 others liked this
TheSkip

TheSkip

Nice note!
Greg Ballington

Greg Ballington Influencer Badge Premium Badge

Worth checking out thanks @Shay Aldriedge!

Sheridan Vineyard

Boss Block Yakima Valley Cabernet Franc 2012

Paul H
9.2

Opens with prevalent graphite, licorice and raspberries. On the palate rich plums and red berries mixed with small amounts of licorice currants and graphite to make a well balanced Cab Franc. This is a really good one but still my favorite is ARNYCA. By all means I hope you try this and make your comparisons. — 11 years ago

Shawn, Daniel and 4 others liked this