Carl Fischer

Wine lover in NYC, particularly obsessed with CA wines. Founding member, Wine Nerd Herd.

993 wines • 234 followers • 147 following

Realm Cellars

Moonracer Cabernet Sauvignon 2016

Carl Fischer

9.5

Carl had this 3 years ago

with David and Mike

Mike, David and 69 others liked this

David L

Fortunate enough to have tried one of the last glasses. Just starting it’s a long journey ahead. Great bottle.

9.5

Massican

Napa Valley Sauvignon Blanc 2018

Carl Fischer

9.3

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Diana, Mike and 6 others

David, Shay and 66 others liked this

Joshua Fisher

If I say I don’t enjoy SB, and I say this is my wine of the year… please understand how good this is.

Ron R

Monday and it’s still drinking beautifully, @Joshua Fisher 👍🏾

Ron R

@Joshua Fisher, I have 2 mags remaining…

Fantesca

Russian River Valley Chardonnay 2009

Carl Fischer

9.6

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Diana, Mike and 6 others

David, Shay and 52 others liked this

David L

Never would’ve guessed this was 2009. Absolute fantastic. Thank you @Ron R

9.5

Aubert

Lauren Vineyard Chardonnay 2015

Carl Fischer

9.5

Carl had this 3 years ago

with David and Mike

Mike, David and 57 others liked this

David L

A Magnum of 15. One of the best Laurens I’ve ever tried.

9.6

Krankl Wine

The Third Twin Graciano 2015

Carl Fischer

9.6

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Eric, Mike and 5 others

Eric, Mike and 57 others liked this

Bryan Kesting

Fun wine to drink…very unique. Would like to try again with 9-10 years of age.

Ron R

I didn’t taste this, Shay.

Bollinger

R.D. Extra Brut Champagne Blend 2002

Carl Fischer

9.3

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Diana, Mike and 6 others

David, Shay and 50 others liked this

Shay A

@Ron R : I wish you could have tried this when we opened it after brunch before we headed to your place!

9.5

Ron R

Oh Shay, I thought this was opened on site at our place. That makes a huge difference…

Hundred Acre Vineyard

Precious Cabernet Sauvignon 2008

Carl Fischer

9.7

Carl had this 3 years ago

with David and Mike

Mike, David and 58 others liked this

Joshua Fisher

Love me some Phillip! Went to the Giants game a few days ago.

Mike R

Amen @Joshua Fisher

Jody Scharf

Wow. 💪

Schrader Cellars

Colesworthy Beckstoffer Las Piedras Cabernet Sauvignon 2013

Carl Fischer

9.6

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Mike, Diana and 6 others

Mike, David and 57 others liked this

Bill Bender

This was a contribution from @Mike R…..I brought the Sparky

Ron R

Corrected @Bill Bender

Ferren Wines

Frei Road Vineyard Chardonnay 2014

Carl Fischer

9.5

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Mike, Diana and 6 others

David, Shay and 52 others liked this

Penfolds

Grange Hermitage Bin 95 Shiraz Cabernet Sauvignon 1993

Carl Fischer

9.6

Carl had this 3 years ago

with Mike, Diana and 6 others

David, Shay and 63 others liked this