One of the few Rye Scotches out there. Definitely got a dry, dusty, rye nose on it. Same in the flavor profile. Some said it tasted like a Whistlepig, I would say maybe more like a Piggyback than any of the others for me which also lines up closer age wise as well. Nice although I wouldn’t describe it to someone as a Scotch and therefore kinda see it more as a novelty. — 6 years ago


Whistlepig Boss Hog. Nose is mostly booze and baking spices. Honestly can't differentiate from the 10 year based solely on nose. Taste is incredibly complex. Heavy spice up front with some sticky plastic. Incredibly layered the rest of the way. Corn biscuit then citrus, honeydew, cantaloupe. Grass, very fresh grass. Numbness in my mouth. Much like when I taste the olde chap. Finally, honey and berry. Best rye I've ever tasted. — 11 years ago
Surprisingly good rye. Apple, pear, caramel, maple syrup, dark chocolate. Very smooth. — 4 years ago


Finishing up an old bottle which watching Phelps swim in Rio. — 10 years ago
Elegant finish. Rich and creamy — 11 years ago
What a big, hefty rye. At 120 proof it packs a punch, but the texture is smooth for something that hot. Vanilla, butterscotch, and cigar are all folded together on the palate with a classic rye nutty-grain finish. Beautiful--and I'm not usually a fan of straight ryes! — 12 years ago
Plumpjack whiskey club winter 2023 — 4 years ago
Love the smooth taste great balance the tickets paid off At the bbq festival — 4 years ago
Wow. Good stuff — 9 years ago
Barrel strength — 11 years ago
Great off the bat. But after a couple drops of water it stopped clearing my sinuses and opened up something fierce. Unreal. — 11 years ago

Paul K
A night of old fashions with my buddy. This was the winner. — 4 months ago