LM Segal

9.4

In a case of truth in labeling, this is the ultimate in peat and salinity, the latter so off the scale as to evoke a sense of pure iodine. A few splashes of water sorted this out, superb. — 13 days ago

with Mark and Joe

Knutte Stenberg

9.0

Mycket mild honung, superlätt utan att vara vattnig, blommig. (Uisge 19) — 14 days ago

AJ Gubser

9.1

Nose is camp fire, pepper, sea breeze, and some faint lemon peel.

Pretty dry up front with big spice/pepper notes. Smoke builds on palate and crescendos in a salty smoked bacon note with some lemon pith. Long, savory finish.

An Islay beauty. Not as much malt or wood sweetness as others, but really nice brine notes and plastic phenolic notes are subdued. Yum. — 5 days ago

Oli Woodland

9.4

Rich, warming and sweet. Caramel, Spice with a light raisin edge...probs from the sherry barrels. — 7 days ago

Paul Treadway Huntington Beacher Bum

9.6

You can’t find a better 25 year old scotch for the price, if price is not an issue go with the 40 year, thats the best scotch I’ve had — 3 days ago

Knutte Stenberg

9.0

Väldigt fyllig, torr, stark men avmätt rökighet — 13 days ago

Alex Zagoro

9.0

I found my peaty bottle that is not just peat :) balanced! — 20 days ago

Alexandre Albore

9.0

Peated with some hint of iodine. Dry and not really invasive with the smoky flavour. — 5 days ago

Jay Kline

9.5

Some of our dear friends muled this bottle from their recent trip to Scotland. Craigellachie is not very well known outside of Scotland as little of it gets bottled under its own label. Instead, the majority goes into blends for Dewars. Bottled at cask-strength, my notes are after four drops of water. This is an explosion of honey, lanolin, Frosted Flakes, pine forest, and bandaid. This is an oily whisky with substantial body. The finish is looooooong...lasting for minutes. Super delicious! — 12 days ago

LM Segal

9.6

Once again Joe pulls the honey and toast elixir. worth every penny of its crazy price! Scotch lovers always keep that 1 bottle hidden for very special friends and occasions. This is it. — 13 days ago

with Melissa, Mark and 1 other