Norman Gennaro

9.2

It felt a bit on the edge. This was a bottle bought not direct from the producer so might have had some impact. Color was not browning but not the normal clean purple so I’m hoping others are better. — 17 days ago

Norman Gennaro

9.7

Close to WOTN — 3 years ago

with Amit and Gunja

Joe Roth

9.3

Nice acid. — 3 years ago

with Jeff and Michael

Kimberly Linthicum

9.6

BIG Pinot. Love. Lingers. — 5 years ago

Austin Blackwell

9.6

Right in its prime. I will wait until the next is 10 years from vintage just out of principle. — 9 months ago

with Angelina

Ron R

9.4

@Mike R and Rhonda - THANK YOU.
Very similar to the Macauley, just a little more extracted. But I felt this was slightly fuller on the palate, with a little more precision with the varietal expression. Again, another youthful wine with runway ahead of it. Marvelous now tho. — 3 years ago

with Mike and Anne-marie

Jason and Jennie

9.4

Gotta give it to this over the macauley napa cab for 2017 — 4 years ago

Norman Gennaro

9.6

Gunja says WOTN. I say Colgin. Supper jammy. — 9 months ago

Jason and Jennie

9.5

This is actually The Claret from Rutherford. 94% cab and 2% of each of the other bordeaux varietals. — 2 years ago

Ron R

9.3

Another wonderful gift from @Mike R and his lovely wife Rhonda.
We rarely drink cab franc, so this was a rare treat. Never as dense as a cab, but presents a lithe texture with a silky smooth mouth feel. Lots of minerality combine with soft oak and overripe cherries. Very well done and complemented our meal perfectly. For its age, it’s still a baby! — 3 years ago

with Mike and Anne-marie