Vinhos Barbeito

The Rare Wine Co. Historic Series Madeira New York Malmsey

9.126 ratings
9.110 pro ratings
Madeira, Portugal
Malmsey
Top Notes For
Delectable Wine

Follow to learn about our favorite wines & people.

9.2

The Madeira New York Malmsey Special Reserve is a rich, heady wine. It offers gorgeous depth and layers that open beautifully in the glass. Dried flowers, cloves, fruitcake, leather, chocolate, cedar and tobacco are nicely amplified in this generous, inviting Madeira. All the elements are so well balanced. This is a stand-out. L22209. (Antonio Galloni, Vinous, December 2022)

The Madeira New York Malmsey Special Reserve is a rich, heady wine. It offers gorgeous depth and layers that open beautifully in the glass. Dried flowers, cloves, fruitcake, leather, chocolate, cedar and tobacco are nicely amplified in this generous, inviting Madeira. All the elements are so well balanced. This is a stand-out. L22209. (Antonio Galloni, Vinous, December 2022)

Dec 9th, 2022
Cathy Corison

Owner/Winemaker Corison Winery

9.1

This WAS dessert.

This WAS dessert.

May 9th, 2019
Austin Hohnke

Really fun way to end the evening. Spiced caramel with nuts and toffee. Long exotic finish. Feel like this would be amazing on pancakes.

Really fun way to end the evening. Spiced caramel with nuts and toffee. Long exotic finish. Feel like this would be amazing on pancakes.

Apr 23rd, 2017
Donald Patz

Owner/Winemaker Patz & Hall

9.1

Classic Madeira.

Classic Madeira.

Feb 23rd, 2016
Jonas Mendoza

Honey, toffee, caramel, coffee, and roasted peanut flavors with fresh acidity. A perfect nitecap for #volcanicsoilstudy

Honey, toffee, caramel, coffee, and roasted peanut flavors with fresh acidity. A perfect nitecap for #volcanicsoilstudy

Jan 13th, 2016
TJ Maxwell

Sweet but alcoholic. Meh. Not as interesting as we'd hoped. But it did wash down desert handily

Sweet but alcoholic. Meh. Not as interesting as we'd hoped. But it did wash down desert handily

Nov 27th, 2015
vino tinto

Syrupy sweet with dark notes of cherries and toasted almonds. Vanilla, molasses, and tobacco.

Syrupy sweet with dark notes of cherries and toasted almonds. Vanilla, molasses, and tobacco.

Mar 8th, 2020
Andrew Schirmer

I remember when this was $30. 😢.
Not that long ago... still delicious but somehow more hollowed out than we remember.

I remember when this was $30. 😢.
Not that long ago... still delicious but somehow more hollowed out than we remember.

Jan 19th, 2020
Michael Walker

Like a tawny port but spicier - goes well with persimmon pudding

Like a tawny port but spicier - goes well with persimmon pudding

Jan 4th, 2017
Peter Heidt

Seattle... One of the white hats brings... Not bad at all; even though I did pour out my coffee and used the same cup for initial sip... So good, I actually got up to find a new clean glass... Good, good time... I feel like I should have signed an NA for some of the stories I heard...

Seattle... One of the white hats brings... Not bad at all; even though I did pour out my coffee and used the same cup for initial sip... So good, I actually got up to find a new clean glass... Good, good time... I feel like I should have signed an NA for some of the stories I heard...

Aug 14th, 2016