Penfolds

Magill Estate Shiraz

9.1119 ratings
9.130 pro ratings
South Australia, Australia
Shiraz
Beef, Venison, Chocolate & Caramel, White Rice, Lamb, Pasta, Potato, Mushrooms, Salami & Prosciutto, Chili & Hot Spicy, Tomato-Based, Pork, Pungent Cheese, Hard Cheese, Onion, Shallot, Garlic
Top Notes For
Bob McDonald

Final Wine from the Magnum Dinner (from 750 ml on this occasion) from the historic Magill Estate , first planted in 1844 by Dr Christopher Rawson Penfold. Only 12 acres. Now enveloped by the suburbs of Adelaide. I tend to only drink Magill Estate in excellent vintages as it lives or dies on a single Vineyard unlike most of the other Penfolds Red Cuvees where they can source fruit from their massive resources throughout South Australia to bolster a poor vintage. Not as oaky or ripe as many other Penfolds reds and the better for it IMO. Plummy earthy minerality with some spice and savoury tannins. Beautifully balanced and the best Magill Estate I’ve ever had.

Final Wine from the Magnum Dinner (from 750 ml on this occasion) from the historic Magill Estate , first planted in 1844 by Dr Christopher Rawson Penfold. Only 12 acres. Now enveloped by the suburbs of Adelaide. I tend to only drink Magill Estate in excellent vintages as it lives or dies on a single Vineyard unlike most of the other Penfolds Red Cuvees where they can source fruit from their massive resources throughout South Australia to bolster a poor vintage. Not as oaky or ripe as many other Penfolds reds and the better for it IMO. Plummy earthy minerality with some spice and savoury tannins. Beautifully balanced and the best Magill Estate I’ve ever had.

Dec 14th, 2017
DLynn

Penfolds Ambassador

9.0

Pretty

Pretty

1 person found it helpfulApr 1st, 2015
DLynn

Penfolds Ambassador

9.5

Maybe better than Grange young

Maybe better than Grange young

1 person found it helpfulMar 23rd, 2015
Donald Patz

Owner/Winemaker Patz & Hall

9.0

It was good. It felt a little old school earthy-cocoa character.

It was good. It felt a little old school earthy-cocoa character.

Jun 5th, 2017
David T

Independent Sommelier/Wine Educator

9.2

Nose of; blackberries, blueberries, plum, black raspberries, violets and soft spices. This 80-90% new oak...2/3 French & 1/3 American. M+ tannins, blueberries, blackberries, black plum, plum, black raspberries, pepper, strong leather, anise, dry crush rocks, mint, tarry notes, red fruits come on the longer finish, tarry notes and a good presence of baking spices. Ripe, round, fruits on a beautifully consistent long finish with very acidity. Photos of some old fortified barrels and a grand display of some very old vintages of; "Hermitage", "Grange" etc. I would love to open and taste but kept under serious lock & key.

Nose of; blackberries, blueberries, plum, black raspberries, violets and soft spices. This 80-90% new oak...2/3 French & 1/3 American. M+ tannins, blueberries, blackberries, black plum, plum, black raspberries, pepper, strong leather, anise, dry crush rocks, mint, tarry notes, red fruits come on the longer finish, tarry notes and a good presence of baking spices. Ripe, round, fruits on a beautifully consistent long finish with very acidity. Photos of some old fortified barrels and a grand display of some very old vintages of; "Hermitage", "Grange" etc. I would love to open and taste but kept under serious lock & key.

Apr 19th, 2017
Michael Meagher MS

Chairman/Founder Boston Sommelier Society, Beverage Director Cafe Escadrille

9.4

So good. Drinking fabulously right now.

So good. Drinking fabulously right now.

Nov 10th, 2016
Ceccherini Cristiano

Bright,showing a little brick in the edge. Marvellous apparence! Nose lead by the wood scents, leather, tobacco, spices, coconut, but also surrounded by a good red berry fruit and a fine minerality. Savoury, irony and meaty in flavour too. Eucaliptus, green tea leaves. Beauty!!✈️

Bright,showing a little brick in the edge. Marvellous apparence! Nose lead by the wood scents, leather, tobacco, spices, coconut, but also surrounded by a good red berry fruit and a fine minerality. Savoury, irony and meaty in flavour too. Eucaliptus, green tea leaves. Beauty!!✈️

Jun 10th, 2016
Michael Meagher MS

Chairman/Founder Boston Sommelier Society, Beverage Director Cafe Escadrille

9.5

One of the greatest single vineyard wines from the new world. Within the city limits of Adelaide, but couldn't be farther from what people expect from Australia. Balanced, savory, power and finesse. From magnum.

One of the greatest single vineyard wines from the new world. Within the city limits of Adelaide, but couldn't be farther from what people expect from Australia. Balanced, savory, power and finesse. From magnum.

Jan 1st, 2016
Ryan Wofford

Very rewarding. Deep rich jammy fruit jumps out. Black cherry, plum, licorice, beautifully soft tannins that still grip on the long finish. #penfolds #shiraz #laborday #treatyoself

Very rewarding. Deep rich jammy fruit jumps out. Black cherry, plum, licorice, beautifully soft tannins that still grip on the long finish. #penfolds #shiraz #laborday #treatyoself

Sep 7th, 2015
Peter van den Besselaar

Tabac, spicy, leather, plums, stable and espresso, what you call a complex nose combined with an elegant taste. Love it.

Tabac, spicy, leather, plums, stable and espresso, what you call a complex nose combined with an elegant taste. Love it.

Nov 4th, 2014