Carlisle Winery & Vineyards

Russian River Valley Syrah

9.116 ratings
9.06 pro ratings
Russian River Valley, Sonoma County, California, USA
Syrah
Lamb
Top Notes For
Bob McDonald

Interesting to taste a Californian Syrah in Australia - a style you don’t often see in bottle shops. I actually bought this bottle in Juuls Wine Shop in Copenhagen several years ago. The wine had a hint of vanilla on nose and palate initially. Earthy with blackberry and herbs - a little sweet (milk chocolate) finishing with silky tannins. Picked from my cellar on the basis of a Thomas Matthews drinking window (2019 to 2024) which is too soon. The winery said 2020 to 2032 which is probably too long. It is definitely an inexact science.

Interesting to taste a Californian Syrah in Australia - a style you don’t often see in bottle shops. I actually bought this bottle in Juuls Wine Shop in Copenhagen several years ago. The wine had a hint of vanilla on nose and palate initially. Earthy with blackberry and herbs - a little sweet (milk chocolate) finishing with silky tannins. Picked from my cellar on the basis of a Thomas Matthews drinking window (2019 to 2024) which is too soon. The winery said 2020 to 2032 which is probably too long. It is definitely an inexact science.

Aug 12th, 2023
Matt Austin

Owner/Winemaker, Grosgrain Vineyards, Walla Walla, WA

9.2

Took about an hour to open up, and once it did, it was a knockout. Continued to improve over three hours until it was gone. Still has substantial tannin and plenty of fruit. Kind of primary really. 15.5% alcohol is well integrated. No hurry to drink these.

Took about an hour to open up, and once it did, it was a knockout. Continued to improve over three hours until it was gone. Still has substantial tannin and plenty of fruit. Kind of primary really. 15.5% alcohol is well integrated. No hurry to drink these.

Jun 23rd, 2015
Matt Forester

Green olives give way to baking spices and black pepper. Giant Syrah. Really good.

Green olives give way to baking spices and black pepper. Giant Syrah. Really good.

Sep 9th, 2020
Dan skoda

Drinking beautifully with candied black fruits truffle and olive tapenade; all the glycerine and seductive fruit of its ripe vintage.

Drinking beautifully with candied black fruits truffle and olive tapenade; all the glycerine and seductive fruit of its ripe vintage.

Aug 7th, 2017
Peggy Hadley

Decanted.

Decanted.

Feb 13th, 2017
Richard Dixon

Nicely balanced, but probably two years past its peak. Went nicely with the lamb ragu pasta I made, as well as the dessert chocolate.

Nicely balanced, but probably two years past its peak. Went nicely with the lamb ragu pasta I made, as well as the dessert chocolate.

Feb 5th, 2017
Juan Menendez

Beautiful.

Beautiful.

Oct 23rd, 2016
Mark Senn

This is a great middle ground between Cali and No Rhone styles. Still has ability to age for 5+ years.

This is a great middle ground between Cali and No Rhone styles. Still has ability to age for 5+ years.

Aug 10th, 2014
Henrik Poulsen

Henrik had this 8 years ago

Henrik had this 8 years ago

Apr 2nd, 2017
Damon Levy

Director/Importer Vine Connections

9.2

Damon had this 11 years ago

Damon had this 11 years ago

Mar 25th, 2014