Kistler

Hudson Vineyard Chardonnay

9.2263 ratings
9.233 pro ratings
Carneros, North Coast, California, USA
Chardonnay
Duck, Shellfish, Goose, Mushrooms, Manchego & Parmesan, Game, Pork, Squash & Root Vegetables, Chicken, Turkey, Cheddar & Gruyere, Meaty & Oily Fish, White Fish, Shellfish, Crab & Lobster, Cream Sauces
Top Notes For
Shawn R

Minerals and a healthy dose of oak.

Minerals and a healthy dose of oak.

Jul 15th, 2020
Shay A
9.3

Thanks to @Mark Flesher for opening this as a side by side versus my 2016 Aubert Hudson. Same vintage, same vineyard source, very different wines. Whereas the Aubert was rich and powerful on both the nose and palate, this was decidedly more herbal on the nose with hay, herbal spices and underripe honeydew. Similar to the Aubert in how round and soft it was initially, but this one has less of the sweet fruit and toasted oak and in turn, has more sea spray, limestone, with added poached pear toward the middle and finish.

Thanks to @Mark Flesher for opening this as a side by side versus my 2016 Aubert Hudson. Same vintage, same vineyard source, very different wines. Whereas the Aubert was rich and powerful on both the nose and palate, this was decidedly more herbal on the nose with hay, herbal spices and underripe honeydew. Similar to the Aubert in how round and soft it was initially, but this one has less of the sweet fruit and toasted oak and in turn, has more sea spray, limestone, with added poached pear toward the middle and finish.

Sep 8th, 2019
John Willison

Over ripe peach, lemon curd, butterscotch.

Over ripe peach, lemon curd, butterscotch.

Aug 30th, 2019
Ron R
9.1

Finally, wifey and I can report some progress. Wine cellar is now finished, and we love it. The germ of the idea came from @Mo Salem when we were in demolition phase. We took it from there. 6 months later, here were are.
Onto the Kistler, which is a lovely example, but I detect it’s on the decline. Having said that, it has a great nose of peaches, honey and pistachios. Visually, you can see that the chassis is a rich, golden color, suggesting corrosion. Palate is creamy and dense. Acid has given way to some cardboard notes, but this is still a good example from a great producer.

Finally, wifey and I can report some progress. Wine cellar is now finished, and we love it. The germ of the idea came from @Mo Salem when we were in demolition phase. We took it from there. 6 months later, here were are.
Onto the Kistler, which is a lovely example, but I detect it’s on the decline. Having said that, it has a great nose of peaches, honey and pistachios. Visually, you can see that the chassis is a rich, golden color, suggesting corrosion. Palate is creamy and dense. Acid has given way to some cardboard notes, but this is still a good example from a great producer.

Mar 22nd, 2019
p w
9.5

badass. Old hudson chardo is seriously important. Recent '96 marcassin hudson also fantastic. good luck finding these. bâtard-level badass.

badass. Old hudson chardo is seriously important. Recent '96 marcassin hudson also fantastic. good luck finding these. bâtard-level badass.

Jun 23rd, 2018
jesus g

Hospitality Schramsberg Vineyards

8.9

I absolutely appreciate the toasted hazelnuts and butterscotch on the nose, but I should of used those 90 dollars towards a Montrachet. It was missing the freshness, a little lift and bright acidity that I’m used to seeing from this producer.

I absolutely appreciate the toasted hazelnuts and butterscotch on the nose, but I should of used those 90 dollars towards a Montrachet. It was missing the freshness, a little lift and bright acidity that I’m used to seeing from this producer.

Mar 6th, 2018
Shay A
9.4

Got to take advantage of another Wednesday Wine Committee and boy was it worth it. Wow! Killer wines brought by Glenn for his 60th! As always, wines tasted blind. 1 sparkler, 3 whites, 4 reds, 1 dessert wine.

A battle between this and the Stone Flat for White of the day, but this edged out. Very little oak presence, but it still had a great body and texture to it without being overly crisp. Some wanted to go to burgundy with this, but the aromatics gave it away...you could tell is was a premier producer's young wine. Lovely stuff.

Got to take advantage of another Wednesday Wine Committee and boy was it worth it. Wow! Killer wines brought by Glenn for his 60th! As always, wines tasted blind. 1 sparkler, 3 whites, 4 reds, 1 dessert wine.

A battle between this and the Stone Flat for White of the day, but this edged out. Very little oak presence, but it still had a great body and texture to it without being overly crisp. Some wanted to go to burgundy with this, but the aromatics gave it away...you could tell is was a premier producer's young wine. Lovely stuff.

Jul 12th, 2017
Yoon Ha

Master Sommelier/Wine Director Benu

9.2

Caramel coated apple on a stick you get at the carnival. I mean this in the most complimentary way possible. The wine is still so alive!

Caramel coated apple on a stick you get at the carnival. I mean this in the most complimentary way possible. The wine is still so alive!

2 people found it helpfulNov 28th, 2013
Joe Wines

Amazing. With tomato essence

Amazing. With tomato essence

1 person found it helpfulAug 11th, 2014
Christanna Honer

Stony minerality, ripe and restrained with honey nut cheerio notes. Elegant, favorite of the lineup.

Stony minerality, ripe and restrained with honey nut cheerio notes. Elegant, favorite of the lineup.

Nov 21st, 2016