Hermann J. Wiemer

Magdalena Vineyard Dry Riesling

9.041 ratings
8.911 pro ratings
Seneca Lake, Finger Lakes, New York, USA
Riesling
Top Notes For
Meg Herring

I tried both the 18 and 19 and liked both, but bought the 18. I was surprised to like the 18 more given the vintage, but I guess that’s why we shouldn’t assume before tasting!

I tried both the 18 and 19 and liked both, but bought the 18. I was surprised to like the 18 more given the vintage, but I guess that’s why we shouldn’t assume before tasting!

Oct 8th, 2020
Matt

Reminds me of Phalz/Alsace with its oily texture, richer character, and slightly diminished acid. Very petrol and mineral with the fruits almost in a supporting background role. Very cool and certainly of high quality. Makes you want to drink more Finger Lakes wines

Reminds me of Phalz/Alsace with its oily texture, richer character, and slightly diminished acid. Very petrol and mineral with the fruits almost in a supporting background role. Very cool and certainly of high quality. Makes you want to drink more Finger Lakes wines

Sep 27th, 2016
Zach Tirone

LCL Bar & Kitchen

9.0

2007.

2007.

Jul 15th, 2015
Thibaut Marquis

Region Manager East, CRU Selections Terlato Wines International

7.8

Actually disappointed. Balance fruits/acidity is lacking. Too sweet. Not structured.

Actually disappointed. Balance fruits/acidity is lacking. Too sweet. Not structured.

Feb 15th, 2015
Robert Love

Green apple, pineapple, and petrol on the nose. Balanced in the mouth, rich with nice acidity. Spicy finish but wish it were longer. Drink now through 2019.

Green apple, pineapple, and petrol on the nose. Balanced in the mouth, rich with nice acidity. Spicy finish but wish it were longer. Drink now through 2019.

Feb 10th, 2015
Robert Love

Pineapple and apple on the nose. Nice weight but a little lackluster on the finish. #Riesling #NY

Pineapple and apple on the nose. Nice weight but a little lackluster on the finish. #Riesling #NY

Dec 20th, 2014
Catherine Gerdes

Beverage director, L'artusi

9.1

Complex Riesling with a stunning nose

Complex Riesling with a stunning nose

Dec 17th, 2014
Christina Turley

Sales & Marketing Turley Wine Cellars

9.0

A stellar example of what NY can do. Goooo Finger Lakes! #nywe14

A stellar example of what NY can do. Goooo Finger Lakes! #nywe14

Oct 18th, 2014
Christopher Bates

Master Sommelier, Owner/Winemaker Element Winery

9.7

#fingerlove. Balanced and elegant. Great structure but a youthful closed baby.

#fingerlove. Balanced and elegant. Great structure but a youthful closed baby.

Oct 1st, 2014
Nick Ribaudo

Strong on the nose with peaches, lemons/limes, and bright citrus. Some mineral like flavors, almost like stones but nice balances to the heavy fruit. I would definitely say give it a try.

Strong on the nose with peaches, lemons/limes, and bright citrus. Some mineral like flavors, almost like stones but nice balances to the heavy fruit. I would definitely say give it a try.

Jun 3rd, 2018