Renato Motalli

Valgella Valtellina Superiore Nebbiolo

9.121 ratings
9.211 pro ratings
Valtellina, Sondrio, Lombardia, Italy
Nebbiolo
Top Notes For
Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.3

Beautiful light color but such clarity. Nose is mega spice and old chestnut. Very complex and ethereal. Faint leather scents. Real fineness to the aromas and breadth. But air will help them more. Palate is wonderful with mid season and sour cherries but also needs to open up and flesh out. Really fine and delicate tannins that build with that earthy sweet fruit on the finish. This also has remarkable finesse. Nose gets sawdust and cigar tobacco now. Really wonderful silky texture and intense minerality on the finish. There is no shortage of brightness and energy here. I’ll be back as I know this will blossom.

Beautiful light color but such clarity. Nose is mega spice and old chestnut. Very complex and ethereal. Faint leather scents. Real fineness to the aromas and breadth. But air will help them more. Palate is wonderful with mid season and sour cherries but also needs to open up and flesh out. Really fine and delicate tannins that build with that earthy sweet fruit on the finish. This also has remarkable finesse. Nose gets sawdust and cigar tobacco now. Really wonderful silky texture and intense minerality on the finish. There is no shortage of brightness and energy here. I’ll be back as I know this will blossom.

Aug 11th, 2022
Tom Casagrande

For such a light-colored 9-year old wine, this is still pretty youthful. Nose is beautiful. Moist earth, cracked mountain rocks, delicate, pure cherry, sweet spice, flowers. Lean but mouthfilling, with the fruit turning savory and minerally quickly after entry. Perfection with a delicate braised chicken dish.

For such a light-colored 9-year old wine, this is still pretty youthful. Nose is beautiful. Moist earth, cracked mountain rocks, delicate, pure cherry, sweet spice, flowers. Lean but mouthfilling, with the fruit turning savory and minerally quickly after entry. Perfection with a delicate braised chicken dish.

Oct 29th, 2019
Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.2

What a nose. Stunning old school Nebbiolo. Maybe my favorite of all the Italian producers we carry. Rose, mineral, leather so feral and wild. Spice and mineral. Juicy, mineral man is this mineral and lovely elegant red fruits. Sappy and so fine. Excellent value. Needs 45 minutes to breathe.

What a nose. Stunning old school Nebbiolo. Maybe my favorite of all the Italian producers we carry. Rose, mineral, leather so feral and wild. Spice and mineral. Juicy, mineral man is this mineral and lovely elegant red fruits. Sappy and so fine. Excellent value. Needs 45 minutes to breathe.

Jun 1st, 2019
Tom Casagrande

Needs a few hours of air time to strut, but then shows wet river stone minerality, fragrant bitter cherry, and a floral note. Lean but flavorful in the mouth, with loads of barely ripe cherry, and lots of savory minerals. Tannins and acids are present but well integrated. Very nice.

Needs a few hours of air time to strut, but then shows wet river stone minerality, fragrant bitter cherry, and a floral note. Lean but flavorful in the mouth, with loads of barely ripe cherry, and lots of savory minerals. Tannins and acids are present but well integrated. Very nice.

Apr 21st, 2019
Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.2

Haunting nose. Sour cherries, feral, gamey, mineral, tarry, elegant, floral, spice. Really nuanced and straight. Terrific. Juicy and complex with terrific purity and Fassy acidity. Very mineral finish. Terrific fruit on the mid palate which expands over a few hours.

Haunting nose. Sour cherries, feral, gamey, mineral, tarry, elegant, floral, spice. Really nuanced and straight. Terrific. Juicy and complex with terrific purity and Fassy acidity. Very mineral finish. Terrific fruit on the mid palate which expands over a few hours.

Jan 1st, 2019
Tom Casagrande

Very light colored, the nose on this wine features sandalwood, dried underbrush, and old cherry liqueur. The flavors are somewhat austere, but feature intense rocky minerality and barely-ripe cherry. Lots of soft tannin, and the finish lasts a surprisingly long time for such a lighter-styled wine. Really good with food, but a little severe without food.

Very light colored, the nose on this wine features sandalwood, dried underbrush, and old cherry liqueur. The flavors are somewhat austere, but feature intense rocky minerality and barely-ripe cherry. Lots of soft tannin, and the finish lasts a surprisingly long time for such a lighter-styled wine. Really good with food, but a little severe without food.

Aug 16th, 2018
Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.3

Dazzling nose. Cool climate neb for the win. So delicate. Tar, dried roses, cherries, and earthy inner earth component. Spice. So nice. Texture is so ethereal and delicate. So juicy and complex with such purity. Nice cut and grip. Excellent freshness and length. Such an honest and authentic wine not lacking soul that’s for sure. Terrific fruit, power and concentration.

Dazzling nose. Cool climate neb for the win. So delicate. Tar, dried roses, cherries, and earthy inner earth component. Spice. So nice. Texture is so ethereal and delicate. So juicy and complex with such purity. Nice cut and grip. Excellent freshness and length. Such an honest and authentic wine not lacking soul that’s for sure. Terrific fruit, power and concentration.

Feb 24th, 2018
Tom Casagrande

Such a delicate, unique wine. Nose has liquified mountain rocks and lilty spiced cherry. In the mouth it is the purest, smoothest essence of stone, wrapped in only a veil of fruit. Nano-grained tannins accompany a surprisingly saline finish. Superb

Such a delicate, unique wine. Nose has liquified mountain rocks and lilty spiced cherry. In the mouth it is the purest, smoothest essence of stone, wrapped in only a veil of fruit. Nano-grained tannins accompany a surprisingly saline finish. Superb

1 person found it helpfulJan 22nd, 2018
Matthew Cohen

Cool climate Nebbiolo with the balance of great volnay. Mose of orange peel and spice. Palate is sweet Nebbiolo fruit with haunting internal aromatics. Lingering sweet fruit finish. I guess fifty years of experience making wine in the same terroir do matter for something. A wine that is a unique expression of Nebbiolo. Bobby got from Fass selections.

Cool climate Nebbiolo with the balance of great volnay. Mose of orange peel and spice. Palate is sweet Nebbiolo fruit with haunting internal aromatics. Lingering sweet fruit finish. I guess fifty years of experience making wine in the same terroir do matter for something. A wine that is a unique expression of Nebbiolo. Bobby got from Fass selections.

1 person found it helpfulJan 15th, 2018
Matthew Cohen

Still good freshness. Elegant cherry fruit. Missing a bit of the vibrancy it had in its youth but still lovely.

As this opens you get lovely pink roses on the nose. This wine still has it. It just needs some time.

Fass selections

Still good freshness. Elegant cherry fruit. Missing a bit of the vibrancy it had in its youth but still lovely.

As this opens you get lovely pink roses on the nose. This wine still has it. It just needs some time.

Fass selections

Apr 24th, 2024