Porter Creek

Old Vine Mendocino County Carignane

9.0195 ratings
9.128 pro ratings
Mendocino, North Coast, California, USA
Carignane
Top Notes For
Stephen Mathews

I agree with some of the statements below, great wine but I don’t think it’s 100% Carignane

I agree with some of the statements below, great wine but I don’t think it’s 100% Carignane

Mar 24th, 2024
Alex Hill

Restrained dark fruit with dusty spicy nuance.

Restrained dark fruit with dusty spicy nuance.

3 people found it helpfulMar 21st, 2015
Holly Evans-White

Juicy berries clean and outrageously delicious and succulent.

Juicy berries clean and outrageously delicious and succulent.

3 people found it helpfulAug 16th, 2014
MICHAEL COOPER DipWSET

Owner TomeVinos wine shops, WSET Level 3, Blogger www.spanishwinesandmore.com, blog.tomevinos.com

8.9

I think @Jordan Mackay described this wine to a tee. While I enjoyed it, I wonder if it’s 100% Carignan. Could there possibly be an error in the identification of the variety? It is actually quite common in Californian vineyards and especially older vineyards to have a mix of varieties or believe it’s one variety because that’s how it was bought, but DNA testing can be surprising. This seems much more Gamay to me. In Paso Robles for example I know of some pretty famous winemakers and important vineyards that thought they had Mourvèdre and it turned out to be Graciano.

I think @Jordan Mackay described this wine to a tee. While I enjoyed it, I wonder if it’s 100% Carignan. Could there possibly be an error in the identification of the variety? It is actually quite common in Californian vineyards and especially older vineyards to have a mix of varieties or believe it’s one variety because that’s how it was bought, but DNA testing can be surprising. This seems much more Gamay to me. In Paso Robles for example I know of some pretty famous winemakers and important vineyards that thought they had Mourvèdre and it turned out to be Graciano.

2 people found it helpfulFeb 11th, 2019
Meg Herring

If you’re looking to switch things up for under $30, this is 🔥.

If you’re looking to switch things up for under $30, this is 🔥.

1 person found it helpfulApr 6th, 2019
Mark Lindzy

Very cool wine, light in color and body, but full of fruit and minerality.

Very cool wine, light in color and body, but full of fruit and minerality.

1 person found it helpfulNov 20th, 2014
Kaila Medina

Dry. A very different varietal that is fun to play with.

Dry. A very different varietal that is fun to play with.

1 person found it helpfulSep 29th, 2013
Jordan Mackay

Wine Editor San Francisco Magazine

9.5

This is the model for the delicious California table wine of the present and the future. Old vines give decent concentration, yet very very light and lovely tannin. Mainly, it's a beautiful expression of purple and dark fruit with a heady perfume and an incredibly soft landing. Price is good. Probably low 20s retail. Competes with good Beaujolais.

This is the model for the delicious California table wine of the present and the future. Old vines give decent concentration, yet very very light and lovely tannin. Mainly, it's a beautiful expression of purple and dark fruit with a heady perfume and an incredibly soft landing. Price is good. Probably low 20s retail. Competes with good Beaujolais.

1 person found it helpfulMay 3rd, 2013
S Butterfield

Sommelier Flask Fine Wines

9.0

Very good and appropriate for the varietal.

Very good and appropriate for the varietal.

May 25th, 2016
Matt Austin

Owner/Winemaker, Grosgrain Vineyards, Walla Walla, WA

8.9

This has a bit of a green streak, but also great texture and lean spicy fruit behind the veg.

This has a bit of a green streak, but also great texture and lean spicy fruit behind the veg.

May 4th, 2016