Carlisle Winery & Vineyards

Sonoma County Syrah

9.1103 ratings
9.126 pro ratings
Sonoma County, California, USA
Syrah
Lamb
Top Notes For
Shay A
9.4

In the running for shocker of the year so far. Not only because of how youthful it was, but in how it cleaned house at a small Syrah tasting with my local group.

I popped this ahead of time to try a glass because I was a bit skeptical of how it would show…my jaw about dropped when I smelled this wine. My goodness…deep and dark florals, violet, stemmy green herbs, black pepper. Wonderfully balanced and integrated on the palate. Whole cluster profile shines through in a supporting role, with the pepper-crusted blackberries, mocha, olive, charcoal. Not rich, not lean, fastball down the middle. Nervy acidity still. This has a cool-climate vibe to it with just a kick of richness to really seduce you. Brilliant. I may have underscored this.

In the running for shocker of the year so far. Not only because of how youthful it was, but in how it cleaned house at a small Syrah tasting with my local group.

I popped this ahead of time to try a glass because I was a bit skeptical of how it would show…my jaw about dropped when I smelled this wine. My goodness…deep and dark florals, violet, stemmy green herbs, black pepper. Wonderfully balanced and integrated on the palate. Whole cluster profile shines through in a supporting role, with the pepper-crusted blackberries, mocha, olive, charcoal. Not rich, not lean, fastball down the middle. Nervy acidity still. This has a cool-climate vibe to it with just a kick of richness to really seduce you. Brilliant. I may have underscored this.

Mar 16th, 2024
Jesse Pender

Assistant Winemaker Delicato Family Vineyards

8.7

A very quiet wine.

A very quiet wine.

Feb 2nd, 2019
Jesse Pender

Assistant Winemaker Delicato Family Vineyards

8.8

Could probably age a touch more.

Could probably age a touch more.

Dec 21st, 2018
Jesse Pender

Assistant Winemaker Delicato Family Vineyards

9.0

Good fruit and oak balance. Decanted. Liked the wine a little better before the decant.

Good fruit and oak balance. Decanted. Liked the wine a little better before the decant.

Oct 9th, 2018
Matt Austin

Owner/Winemaker, Grosgrain Vineyards, Walla Walla, WA

9.0

Solid, but very young. Better on day 2. Interesting to see this under screwcap now.

Solid, but very young. Better on day 2. Interesting to see this under screwcap now.

Jul 10th, 2016
Chris MacLean

Fun to taste right after the Jamet Syrah. Sweet, oaky and brawny, but persistent, complex and well-made.

Fun to taste right after the Jamet Syrah. Sweet, oaky and brawny, but persistent, complex and well-made.

May 1st, 2016
Patrick Derdeyn

The basic syrah offering from Mike Officer provides so much value. Don't love as much as the 13 but this is always amazing for the price.

The basic syrah offering from Mike Officer provides so much value. Don't love as much as the 13 but this is always amazing for the price.

Apr 22nd, 2016
Lee Lightfoot

Could pass for high end paso juice. Great value for balanced full bodied New world style Syrah.

Could pass for high end paso juice. Great value for balanced full bodied New world style Syrah.

Jan 24th, 2016
Reid Kinnett

Big boy, fairly woody, very dry

Big boy, fairly woody, very dry

Apr 21st, 2015