Tenet Wines

The Pundit Columbia Valley Syrah

9.034 ratings
9.06 pro ratings
Columbia Valley, Oregon/Washington, USA
Syrah
Lamb
Top Notes For
Tom Casagrande

Our inn doesn’t allow BYOW in the rooms. Something about their liquor license. So, off the very limited wine list, I got this.

I shouldn’t have read the back label first. I saw “consultant Philippe Cambie.”

F*ck.

And sure enough, this tastes a lot like the overripe, overextracted Syrah-heavy Cotes du Rhône Villages that he has all his clients make. Maybe a tad better, since Syrah is better suited to the Columbia Valley than the Southern Rhône, so at least some of its vibrant savory character comes through.

Still, I wish that guy would go full Hobbit and move to New Zealand to f*ck up wines I never drink anyway.

UPDATE: The next night, this seemed a little less fruit-bomby. Upping from 8.6 to 8.7.

Our inn doesn’t allow BYOW in the rooms. Something about their liquor license. So, off the very limited wine list, I got this.

I shouldn’t have read the back label first. I saw “consultant Philippe Cambie.”

F*ck.

And sure enough, this tastes a lot like the overripe, overextracted Syrah-heavy Cotes du Rhône Villages that he has all his clients make. Maybe a tad better, since Syrah is better suited to the Columbia Valley than the Southern Rhône, so at least some of its vibrant savory character comes through.

Still, I wish that guy would go full Hobbit and move to New Zealand to f*ck up wines I never drink anyway.

UPDATE: The next night, this seemed a little less fruit-bomby. Upping from 8.6 to 8.7.

Dec 3rd, 2017
Sondra Bernstein

Owner of the girl & the fig, the fig cafe & winebar, Author of Plats du Jours, the girl & the fig's Journey through the Seasons in Wine Country and the girl & the fig Cookbook

9.0

Cocoa- coffee- cigar aromas -- dark berry fruit,

Cocoa- coffee- cigar aromas -- dark berry fruit,

1 person found it helpfulApr 15th, 2016
John Howard

Harvest production at Hirsch and Cobb Wineries

8.9

Ditto on the my last review. Almost like if A Cote Rotie was dunked into an American oak barrel for year and a half. Ok , not really, it just needs a lot of air to smooth out.

Ditto on the my last review. Almost like if A Cote Rotie was dunked into an American oak barrel for year and a half. Ok , not really, it just needs a lot of air to smooth out.

Apr 20th, 2017
Andrew Holod

National Sales Grapes of Spain

9.3

Violets, blueberry skin, black olive. Very complex, deliciously balanced with both plenty of yum fruit and plenty of layered complexity on the long finish.

Violets, blueberry skin, black olive. Very complex, deliciously balanced with both plenty of yum fruit and plenty of layered complexity on the long finish.

Feb 13th, 2017
Jesse Pender

Assistant Winemaker Delicato Family Vineyards

9.0

New world meets old world.

New world meets old world.

Jan 21st, 2017
Matt Sterr

Rhine-esque. Earthy and dark. Graphite.

Rhine-esque. Earthy and dark. Graphite.

Dec 14th, 2016
Isaac Pirolo

Opened on election night and it turned out to be the only pundit worth paying attention to.

Opened on election night and it turned out to be the only pundit worth paying attention to.

Nov 9th, 2016
Isaac Pirolo

Just as good as the 2013. Lavender and sweet, dark fruit, with some orange peel potpourri.

Just as good as the 2013. Lavender and sweet, dark fruit, with some orange peel potpourri.

Jun 23rd, 2016
Geoff Troup

Sales Eder Brothers, Cellar Fine Wines

8.9

New vintage. Quite nice, a bit more restrained and certainly a bit wound up. A little time in the bottle should fix that no problem.

New vintage. Quite nice, a bit more restrained and certainly a bit wound up. A little time in the bottle should fix that no problem.

May 10th, 2016
Edward Nelson

16 and counting.

16 and counting.

Jun 23rd, 2018