Matthew Rorick of Forlorn Hope

Riesling

9.011 ratings
9.010 pro ratings
Santa Barbara County, Central Coast, California, USA
Riesling
Pork, Squash & Root Vegetables, Chili & Hot Spicy, White Fish, Fruit Desserts, Meaty & Oily Fish, Duck, Goat & Feta Cheese, Blue Cheese
Top Notes For
Michael Solway

I have rarely disliked a wine so emphatically that I've given such a poor rating. In fact, when I taste a wine as disappointing as this one I usually refrain from commentary, but as a public service to Riesling lovers everywhere I'll share my thoughts on this bottling. If you are growing cool climate grapes in what equates to a Mediterranean climate why would you pick underripe berries to prove your point of making a 10% ABV Riesling? Sad, sour, thin and anemic. A wine devoid of any texture and charm. Everything I love about Riesling is missing.

I have rarely disliked a wine so emphatically that I've given such a poor rating. In fact, when I taste a wine as disappointing as this one I usually refrain from commentary, but as a public service to Riesling lovers everywhere I'll share my thoughts on this bottling. If you are growing cool climate grapes in what equates to a Mediterranean climate why would you pick underripe berries to prove your point of making a 10% ABV Riesling? Sad, sour, thin and anemic. A wine devoid of any texture and charm. Everything I love about Riesling is missing.

Jun 26th, 2016
Helen Keplinger

Owner/Winemaker Keplinger Wines

9.1

There's nothing he can't do...

There's nothing he can't do...

Mar 14th, 2015
Patrick Dorsey

Riesling from California......and it's good?! Really good. Nice zip. The fruit is starting to show itself a little more and is a welcome addition to the program. Would love to do this side-by-side with Tatomer's from the same site.

Riesling from California......and it's good?! Really good. Nice zip. The fruit is starting to show itself a little more and is a welcome addition to the program. Would love to do this side-by-side with Tatomer's from the same site.

Dec 14th, 2014
Chris Cottrell

Partner Bedrock Wine Co, Co-founder/Winemaker Under the Wire

9.8

Not missing my first loves from Germany @ Locals Corner

Not missing my first loves from Germany @ Locals Corner

May 5th, 2014
Steve Matthiasson

Owner/Winemaker Matthiasson Wines

9.9

Domestic Riesling with minerality and focus--gotta grab a case

Domestic Riesling with minerality and focus--gotta grab a case

Jan 26th, 2014
Ben Brenner

Ben had this 11 years ago

Ben had this 11 years ago

Sep 4th, 2014
Marshal White

Marshal had this 11 years ago

Marshal had this 11 years ago

Aug 7th, 2014
Ian Barry

Ian had this 11 years ago

Ian had this 11 years ago

Jun 6th, 2014
Joe Carroll

Owner/Wine Director Spuyten Duyvil, Fette Sau, St. Anselm & Gotham Artisanal Provisions

8.8

Joe had this 11 years ago

Joe had this 11 years ago

Feb 26th, 2014
Jenna Congdon

Sales Wine Wise/The Vienna Wine Co.

9.7

Jenna had this 11 years ago

Jenna had this 11 years ago

Jan 13th, 2014