d'Arenberg

The Dead Arm McLaren Vale Shiraz

9.228 ratings
9.17 pro ratings
McLaren Vale, Fleurieu, South Australia, Australia
Shiraz
Beef, Venison, Chocolate & Caramel, White Rice, Lamb, Pasta, Potato, Mushrooms, Salami & Prosciutto, Chili & Hot Spicy, Tomato-Based, Pork, Pungent Cheese, Hard Cheese, Onion, Shallot, Garlic
Top Notes For
David Kline

Shhh-yeah.

Shhh-yeah.

Mar 30th, 2018
Les Huisman

Funny thing about drinking this after the Grange, there were so many similar flavors, yet they seemed about the same place in their evolution. Smoky and leathery. Held up well, in my opinion.

Funny thing about drinking this after the Grange, there were so many similar flavors, yet they seemed about the same place in their evolution. Smoky and leathery. Held up well, in my opinion.

Aug 20th, 2015
Rafael Landestoy

Beautiful wine.

Beautiful wine.

Jul 25th, 2014
Andrew Lampasone

Owner Wine Watch Selections

9.8

Drinking at its peak right now!!

Drinking at its peak right now!!

Jul 25th, 2014
Brooke Gannon

Wild, brambly, leathery, earth, black pepper, Spicy. A real gem!

Wild, brambly, leathery, earth, black pepper, Spicy. A real gem!

May 1st, 2023
Aaron Rankin

With my bottle I have to disagree with recent reviews. What we have here is a hollowed out, decrepit, less abled (forgive my poor pun) bottle. The nose and textures are interesting, but the palette is a runaway, melty acidic runoff.

Unlike its more endowed 2001 sibling, this 1998 bad boy has lost the little mojo it received at birth. And its remaining arm. Drink up now.

With my bottle I have to disagree with recent reviews. What we have here is a hollowed out, decrepit, less abled (forgive my poor pun) bottle. The nose and textures are interesting, but the palette is a runaway, melty acidic runoff.

Unlike its more endowed 2001 sibling, this 1998 bad boy has lost the little mojo it received at birth. And its remaining arm. Drink up now.

Nov 5th, 2022
President Obama

Derek's

Derek's

Jun 2nd, 2019
Jack Thompson

I have no business drinking some of these wines, but am so glad to have been included in this blind tasting.

I have no business drinking some of these wines, but am so glad to have been included in this blind tasting.

Jun 13th, 2018
Robert Harmelin

Lovely wine with lots of jammy fruit flavors still abounding. A bit short on the finish

Lovely wine with lots of jammy fruit flavors still abounding. A bit short on the finish

Jan 1st, 2016
Roy Piper

1998... Right at the point where the fruit is fading and cedar and forest floor aromas are pushing through. Drink now. Surprised how well his has hung in there.

1998... Right at the point where the fruit is fading and cedar and forest floor aromas are pushing through. Drink now. Surprised how well his has hung in there.

Jun 20th, 2015