Caretaker Wines

Santa Maria Valley Pinot Noir

8.4309 ratings
8.11 pro ratings
Santa Maria Valley, Central Coast, California, USA
Pinot Noir
Turkey, Game, Exotic Spices, Soft Cheese, Duck, Goose, Salads & Greens, Potato, Quinoa, Farro, Brown Rice, White Rice, Pasta, Herbs, Nuts & Seeds, Mushrooms, Chicken, Meaty & Oily Fish, Shellfish, Crab & Lobster, Stew, Onion, Shallot, Garlic, Salami & Prosciutto, Salmon, Quinoa, Shellfish
Top Notes For
Chris B.

Smelled like pure burnt charcoal when I opened it. Tasted like overripe plum and strawberries but got considerably smoother after sitting in the decanter for a half hour. Still, a little too young and sassy for me.

Smelled like pure burnt charcoal when I opened it. Tasted like overripe plum and strawberries but got considerably smoother after sitting in the decanter for a half hour. Still, a little too young and sassy for me.

3 people found it helpfulOct 9th, 2016
Katie Watson

Light, easy to drink in summer

Light, easy to drink in summer

2 people found it helpfulAug 25th, 2014
Neil Jones

Light, almost watery?

Light, almost watery?

2 people found it helpfulAug 17th, 2014
Cyrus Limón

Decent. Too much oak though.

Decent. Too much oak though.

2 people found it helpfulJul 24th, 2014
Lance E. Farman

Not ethereal but good value.

Not ethereal but good value.

Mar 13th, 2015
Lyndsey Wegner

Closer to the Reds I'm currently liking right now (Pommard), but perhaps more on the over-ripe side, especially after it's been opened for a day. It's definitely jammy strawberries, with some dark ripe plums, acidity (location and soils - shale, limestone and sandy loam), dance-ability and fun on the palate right after opening. More cherry and oak notes after 24 hours but overall something that goes really well with food (heirloom tomatoes and burrata, white and pink pasta sauces). When I saw Santa Maria Valley I knew I'd like this wine and I would definitely buy this again!

Closer to the Reds I'm currently liking right now (Pommard), but perhaps more on the over-ripe side, especially after it's been opened for a day. It's definitely jammy strawberries, with some dark ripe plums, acidity (location and soils - shale, limestone and sandy loam), dance-ability and fun on the palate right after opening. More cherry and oak notes after 24 hours but overall something that goes really well with food (heirloom tomatoes and burrata, white and pink pasta sauces). When I saw Santa Maria Valley I knew I'd like this wine and I would definitely buy this again!

May 13th, 2024
Kerri

Very light bodied, light red fruits, trader Joe's find. Ok

Very light bodied, light red fruits, trader Joe's find. Ok

Mar 20th, 2024
Kerri

Easy drinker found at Trader Joe's. Would buy again. Light bodied, light tannins, nice easy fruity flavors

Easy drinker found at Trader Joe's. Would buy again. Light bodied, light tannins, nice easy fruity flavors

Oct 16th, 2022
Stephanie Knapp

Light. Decent value

Light. Decent value

Sep 6th, 2021
Robin Seuc

Does not taste like a Pinot Noir. Oaky finish that reminds me of a Chardonnay. And I don’t like Chardonnay because of the oakiness.

Does not taste like a Pinot Noir. Oaky finish that reminds me of a Chardonnay. And I don’t like Chardonnay because of the oakiness.

Jun 27th, 2021