Dave

9.2

An exceptional wheater. Sweet heat, a little peat. Not rye, wheat... what else rhymes? The 90 proof makes it a bit thin compared to the Antique 107, but it's in the same wheelhouse and I wouldn't kick it out of bed for eating pickled herring.
Listening to Buck Owens and his Buckaroos — 3 months ago

Brent Bailey

9.1

Beautiful bourbon, nice amount of oak, brown sugar, vanilla and easy to drink. — 7 years ago

Mike Smith

Owner/Winemaker Myriad Cellars

9.6

Bottled in 1948. Fire water time for our fire day — 9 years ago

Matt Howell

9.0

A smooth, easy drinking bourbon. Affordable so it's an excellent option for an everyday bourbon. — 10 years ago

Kevin O'Connor

10

Was looking through my dads liquor cabinet and found 9 bottles of bourbon from my grandfathers liquor store that he owned in the 60's. This is a bottle from the original Pappy Van Winkle! There was this bottle and two bottles of Old Fitzgerald bottled in bond from the 1960's. I came up big here and the Stitzel-Weller juice in the bottle does not disappoint. I've never had a spirit like this before. It is ethereal and I have no way to describe it. I can understand how this stuff goes for $350 a pour at whiskey bars. I am seriously without words for this, it is so incredibly amazing. — 10 years ago

eamon gallagher

9.6

mmm. treated like weller. — a year ago

Alvaro Bustillos

9.1

Kentucky YPO Bourbon trip 11/16 — 6 years ago

ADAM STROMFELD

9.7

Yes!! BTAC at its best. What a great pre-dinner treat! Carmel on the nose. Sherry sweet cherries and butterscotch — 8 years ago

Mike Smith

Owner/Winemaker Myriad Cellars

10

5 year Stilzel Weller bottled in 1950. — 9 years ago

Ryan Mayes

9.5

The final drops... from this bottle.. of one of the last vintages a Stitzel Weller juice... her twin and older sister sits on the shelf beside her. Is it good? Of course. But is it worth the opportunity cost of whoever many cases of any other bourbon? I don't know. — 10 years ago

Albert Lin

10

Marzipan. Cherry. Rum. Raisins. — 10 years ago

Charles Hetzel

10

1965 Old Fitzgerald Ky. Straight Bourbon Whiskey (Stitzel Weller) — 11 years ago

Norman

9.8

WhiskeyFest SF 2022 - Bourbon of the night. Just wow. This was the only picture I could get since the table was packed earlier. Others tasted -
William Larue Weller (best)
Thomas H. Handy (3rd best)
George T. Stagg (2020 Release) (2nd best)
Stagg Jr. (no comparison)
Parker’s Heritage Collection Wheat (these are different)
Sazerac - 18 yr. (4th best) — 4 years ago

Matt Sterr

9.3

7 YO Age statement. Dark amber color. Vanilla, caramel, butterscotch and creme brûlée. This is one they should bring back and a great example of a classic bourbon 🥃 bottling. — 7 years ago

with P and Alex

Mike Smith

Owner/Winemaker Myriad Cellars

9.9

Louisville bottling — 8 years ago

David

9.0

Smooth, nice drink — 10 years ago

Charles Hetzel

10

2015 John E. Fitzgerald 20 year old Stitzel Weller Bourbon #Bourbon #Whiskey #Stitzel_Weller — 10 years ago

Richard Shin

10

Amazing aged whiskey. Typical Stitzel-Weller profile, with a smooth entry, and delicious wheated flavor. Hard to put this one down! — 11 years ago

Harold Trimmer

10

1972 stitzel, one of the last years pappy himself had control over. — 13 years ago

with Max