First Creek Wines

Winemaker's Reserve Shiraz

8.86 ratings
-no pro ratings
Hunter Valley, New South Wales, Australia
Shiraz
Beef, Venison, Chocolate & Caramel, White Rice, Lamb, Pasta, Potato, Mushrooms, Salami & Prosciutto, Chili & Hot Spicy, Tomato-Based, Pork, Pungent Cheese, Hard Cheese, Onion, Shallot, Garlic
Top Notes For
Delectable Blue

We tasted this wine at the cellar door and thought it was very nice but tonight it tastes quite mediocre. I’m a big fan of Hunter Valley shiraz, but this one just does not make the grade.

There is plenty of ripe blackberry and mulberry on the palate, with a hint of woodsmoke and tar adding some complexity. But I find the tannins badly lacking and the balance is off. I’m not sure if Shiraz suffers from a “dumb” phase, but I’m hoping more time improves the experience. Certainly not worth the $50 paid for it.

We tasted this wine at the cellar door and thought it was very nice but tonight it tastes quite mediocre. I’m a big fan of Hunter Valley shiraz, but this one just does not make the grade.

There is plenty of ripe blackberry and mulberry on the palate, with a hint of woodsmoke and tar adding some complexity. But I find the tannins badly lacking and the balance is off. I’m not sure if Shiraz suffers from a “dumb” phase, but I’m hoping more time improves the experience. Certainly not worth the $50 paid for it.

Mar 12th, 2016
Kathryn Bache

Good but prob not worth the 100% markeup

Good but prob not worth the 100% markeup

Nov 30th, 2013
Greg Parrott

Greg had this 9 years ago

Greg had this 9 years ago

Jan 13th, 2016
Laree Wasson

Laree had this 9 years ago

Laree had this 9 years ago

Aug 21st, 2015
Michael Giles

Michael had this 10 years ago

Michael had this 10 years ago

Jan 18th, 2015
Mark Everett

Mark had this 11 years ago

Mark had this 11 years ago

Feb 17th, 2014