We use cookies for analytics and to improve our site. You agree to our use of cookies by closing this message box or continuing to use our site. To find out more, including how to change your settings, see our Cookie Policy.
Dismiss

Brotherhood Winery

New York Premium Selection Merlot

8.526 ratings
9.01 pro ratings
Hudson River, New York, USA
Merlot
Beef, Venison, Salami & Prosciutto, Chili & Hot Spicy, Potato, Exotic Spices, Lamb, White Rice, Baking Spices, Herbs, Pasta, Chicken, Mushrooms, Pungent Cheese, Turkey, Tomato-Based, Soft Cheese, Pork, Beans & Peas, Hard Cheese, Duck, Onion, Shallot, Garlic

Explore related

Brotherhood WineryHudson River, New YorkMerlot
Top Notes For
Nolan Berlin
8.3

As expected from a Long Island Merlot, like a flatter version of its Bordeaux cousins. Plum heavy fruit with an oaky finish, but not much depth. It hits what it's trying to, but it lacks any real depth. Brotherhood has more interesting alternatives.

As expected from a Long Island Merlot, like a flatter version of its Bordeaux cousins. Plum heavy fruit with an oaky finish, but not much depth. It hits what it's trying to, but it lacks any real depth. Brotherhood has more interesting alternatives.

Dec 13th, 2025
Kyle
6.2

You call that a full bodied wine?

You call that a full bodied wine?

Aug 23rd, 2015
Kyle
6.9

Best of NY reds, but that's not saying much.

Best of NY reds, but that's not saying much.

Aug 23rd, 2015
Andrew Plant
9.0

Andrew had this 10 years ago

Andrew had this 10 years ago

Apr 13th, 2016
R Flynn
8.0

R had this 8 years ago

R had this 8 years ago

Nov 25th, 2018
Ólafur Einarsson
8.7

Ólafur had this 8 years ago

Ólafur had this 8 years ago

Jun 8th, 2018
Paula Guzman
8.5

Paula had this 9 years ago

Paula had this 9 years ago

Mar 15th, 2017
Tom Colangelo
8.7

Tom had this 9 years ago

Tom had this 9 years ago

Jan 13th, 2017
Shana Drinnan
9.5

Shana had this 10 years ago

Shana had this 10 years ago

Dec 30th, 2016
Kathryn Weber
7.6

Kathryn had this 10 years ago

Kathryn had this 10 years ago

Nov 30th, 2016