Bob McDonald

9.4

Smoky with brief notes from me. Not as peaty as you would expect from the western isles. Had a tour of this distillery some years ago on the Isle of Skye which is the spiritual home of the Clan Donald ie McDonald. Probably prefer the peaty styles of Lagavulin and Laphroig. — 18 days ago

Eric Urbani

8.9

Interesting — 2 years ago

Ichiro Kawachi

9.1

Christmas fruit cake, candies fruit — 3 years ago

Rob Krapf

9.0

Excellent Islay malt. Lovely. warm color. Medium peatiness with creamy and fruity notes. Lingering spice and smoke. — 4 years ago

RG Walker

9.1

Excellent smooth drinking and favorable. — 15 days ago

Ryan Vento

9.0

Nice nightcap 🥃 — 3 years ago

Rusty Beall

9.2

Very peaty! I would have guessed, if I were blindfolded, that it was a Laphroaig. — 4 years ago

David Koenen

9.2

Really good. Thanks J. Thanks S. — 3 months ago

Severn Goodwin

9.3

How does anyone not hoard (regular) Sazerac at ~$25?!
Incredibly smooth, great sweet note to the finish. Again, why haven't I not been buying this for years...?

(BTW Kirkland Bourbon at $30 is worth the price of admission, earthy oak note on the palate is quite similar to Buffalo Trace.)

Counter-Clockwise from top left:
Buffalo Trace (single-barrel selection), Jefferson's Reserve Very Old/Very Small Batch, Knob Creek (9yo), Kirkland Bourbon (7yo), St George single-malt (SM 015), Hillrock (Ancram NY, solera aged, Barrel No. 174), Berkshire Mountain Distillers Shay's Rebellion and Wild Turkey Master's Keep (Batch 0001, 17yo). — 8 months ago

Mark Detrick

8.9

Not a great nose. Smooth and easy to drink. Nice flavors. A beautiful Scotch. — 4 years ago

with Kristen