Held up well for nine years. Ripe red Berry nose, good Zin acidity with a smooth coco finish — 8 years ago
Leathery, slightly smokey, big tannins. Needs a few years — 9 years ago
Lots of life in this gem. A nice tannic backbone and great dark fruit/currant nose. "Rutherford dust" is captured well in this vintage. — 7 years ago
Maybe one of the best California Pinot Noirs. Well balanced despite age, lush but good acidity. Cedar notes on finish. Raspberry and currant on the nose. Wish I had more! — 8 years ago
Leathry, coffee, tobacco with rich, dark fruit nose. Deep in color for being 11 years ago. Tannins holding strong. Spiced blueberry pie on the palette. — 9 years ago
Too sweet! — 7 years ago
Wow! Aging well. Strong on nose with bramble bush, tobacco, cherry. Good acidity. Very little age noted. — 8 years ago
Eric had this 8 years ago
Damn near perfect. 2004 and still well balanced. Violet, cedar on nose. Tons of fruit on palette. One of the better mountain cabs I have had. Highly recommended. — 9 years ago
Eric Eustace
Great fruit character. A bit heavy on the tannin but a really good, drinkable cab. Will revisit this one several times — 7 years ago