Held up well for nine years. Ripe red Berry nose, good Zin acidity with a smooth coco finish — 9 years ago
Leathery, slightly smokey, big tannins. Needs a few years — 10 years ago
Lots of life in this gem. A nice tannic backbone and great dark fruit/currant nose. "Rutherford dust" is captured well in this vintage. — 8 years ago
Maybe one of the best California Pinot Noirs. Well balanced despite age, lush but good acidity. Cedar notes on finish. Raspberry and currant on the nose. Wish I had more! — 9 years ago
Leathry, coffee, tobacco with rich, dark fruit nose. Deep in color for being 11 years ago. Tannins holding strong. Spiced blueberry pie on the palette. — 10 years ago
Too sweet! — 9 years ago
Wow! Aging well. Strong on nose with bramble bush, tobacco, cherry. Good acidity. Very little age noted. — 9 years ago
Eric had this 10 years ago
Damn near perfect. 2004 and still well balanced. Violet, cedar on nose. Tons of fruit on palette. One of the better mountain cabs I have had. Highly recommended. — 10 years ago
Eric Eustace
Great fruit character. A bit heavy on the tannin but a really good, drinkable cab. Will revisit this one several times — 8 years ago