Bob McDonald

9.0

I bought this litre bottle at Easter earlier this year duty free when we visited Norfolk Island. Typical Barbados Rum with caramel and vanilla notes. I only ever have it with a small block of ice. The palate shows same caramel with some charred burnt notes. Some tasters detect Banana notes. Only 37.5 % ABV. This was an occasional after dinner sipper through the winter months. I finished it off last night. — 16 days ago

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

9.4

I didn't know Mount Gay made a Silver!?! Love it! All of their products turn out to be very smooth. — 10 years ago

Kir Beardy

9.6

Favourite rum ever. Always must be on my table. — 11 years ago

Simon Weston

9.2

Delicious fruit nose and sweet tropical fruit taste with molasses, long smooth fiery finish. — 7 years ago

Gary Ferrer

9.0

Absolutely fantastic. Can't go wrong. Easy to sip straight. — 8 years ago

Josh MacGregor

9.1

If you're gonna drink rum, might as well be this. Average aged 8 - 15 years in bourbon barrels. — 11 years ago

Jonas Johansson

9.8

Time to dress the Christmas tree — 11 years ago

Ryota Morikawa

9.7

Rich flavor not too sweet. Kind like whiskey. Recommended straight or rock but also nice with coke or tonic. This has significantly changed my impression for rum. My best rum. — 8 years ago

Martin G Rivard

9.3

All of the wines this evening were donated from my cellar for an international Food & Wine Society dinner function.. The night usually ends with a port but I decided to change it to an aged rum. This drank like a million bucks. Had a nose like a great cognac. Definitely a keeper! — 9 years ago

with David, Paul and 3 others

Antoine Pin

Wine Buyer Kroger/QFC

8.9

All time best rum. Drinks like a cognac. $NA / 97pts — 11 years ago