Variations on a Theme: Burgundy 2020 Whites

Once more, unto the breach, we go. Glutton for punishment that I am, it was time to head back to Savigny-lès-Beaune, drive up the long meandering lane through dense woodland patrolled by wild boar until I reached the isolated converted farmhouse, Hameau de Barbaron. Once here, I left my ego at the door, tied on my metaphorical blindfold and tasted 226 white Burgundy wines that, this year, were the 2020 intake. It bears repeating that this five-day tasting is easily the most educational of the year. I often think such a test should be compulsory for any professional critic, irrespective of experience. The amount learned by listening to fellow participants, understanding their perspective and discovering what might evade your own senses is an invaluable tool, to wit, an exercise in self-improvement. This annual tasting was incepted many years ago under the auspice of the late Clive Coates MW. It was less formal in its early days, though the format has settled and been maintained over the last decade. This group of experienced palates comprises predominantly of the UK’s major Burgundy buyers dotted with a couple of scribes. Members do not change, abiding by the rule that the seat is yours unless you resign or die. Thankfully, unlike “Southwold,” Burgfest has only seen resignations, graciously making way for younger blood and, long overdue, women. Bottles are donated by participating domaines; Premier and Grand Crus only due to time limitations. Flights are arranged per climat with more or less one appellation broached each day. What I particularly like about this tasting is the pace. We take our time, sufficient to re-taste and comprehend Burgundy’s mercurial nature. Crucially, it allows intra-group debate about the wines before they are revealed to customary oohs and aahs. It is a comparative exercise taken to its zenith. Ceteris paribus, variations between wines within flights are influenced by natural differences in terms of terroirs (soil type, altitude, orientation, vine age, rootstock) and human differences (pruning method, canopy management, hours spent in the vineyard etc). One must not overlook the imprint of important decisions: date of picking, sorting, whole bunch addition, alcoholic fermentation and élevage. Given this array of influencing factors, it is remarkable how flights can taste like variations on a theme and therein lies our fascination with Burgundy. This year, I have decided to split the report into white and red, the latter penciled in for early September as usual. This is partly because I am slammed with the marathon of domaine visits later, and it relieves some of the pressure both for myself and the editorial team towards the end of the year. Readers should click here for a summary of the 2020 growing season. So, without further ado, let’s talk about the wines… THE WINES The headline? I was immensely impressed by the quality of the 2020 white Burgundies. They surpassed expectations, a sentiment that was shared by the group. Generally, these seem superior to their 2019 counterparts thanks to, at times, their spine-tingling nervosité that was presumed impossible given that year’s heat. Whoever claims that modern white Burgundy has lost its typicité and edginess should taste the wines instead of theorizing. As I wrote in a previous report, two plus two does not necessarily equal four. In vino veritas and all that. As a consequence, you will find upgrades in my scores vis-à-vis in barrel back in 2021, wines that have gained complexity and terroir expression. --Neal Martin, Variations on a Theme: Burgundy 2020 Whites, July 2024 To read even more about the wines at this year’s Burgfest tasting, check out the full article on Vinous now . Enjoy a few of Neal’s tasting notes below.

Louis Jadot

Domaine des Héritiers Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru Chardonnay 2020

Delectable Wine
9.3

The 2020 Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru doesn't possess the delineation and panache of Tollot-Beaut's on the nose at first, though it coheres nicely with aeration. Peach skin, linseed and wilted white flowers eventually come through. The palate is well-balanced with a viscous entry, a little more honeyed in style than previous wines in this flight of Corton-Charlemagne, though it deserves applause for the precision and detail on the finish. It needs a little more time in the bottle compared to others because there is a lot of coconut-ty new oak. My score is based on this being assimilated with bottle age. Tasted blind at the annual Burgfest tasting. (Neal Martin, Vinous, July 2024)
— 3 months ago

Bitouzet-Prieur

Meursault Charmes 1er Cru Chardonnay 2020

Delectable Wine
9.1

The 2020 Meursault Les Charmes 1er Cru has a reductive bouquet that initially obscures some of the terroir expression. That reduction seems to bed in when I return to the glass after ten minutes. The palate is rich and viscous at the entry, and the acidity thankfully maintains tension. The finish feels pure but a bit predictable. Potentially, a lovely mouthful of Meursault, depending on how that reduction pans out, yet intuition is that it doesn't have the class of the best wines in the appellation. Tasted blind at the annual Burgfest tasting. (Neal Martin, Vinous, July 2024)
— 3 months ago

Rob liked this

Domaine François et Antoine Jobard

Meursault-Genevrières 1er Cru Chardonnay 2020

Delectable Wine
9.4

The 2020 Meursault Genevrières 1er Cru has a subtle reduction on the nose that enhances the aromatics. It is well-defined, with more yellow fruit in situ, crushed stone and rosemary oil. The oak is very well integrated. The palate is energetic and tensile from the start, with the reduction just right. It is not a deep Genevrières, yet taut and linear, almost Puligny-like towards the sustained finish. Excellent, though it needs bottle age to work through the reduction. Tasted blind at the annual Burgfest tasting. (Neal Martin, Vinous, July 2024)
— 3 months ago

Rob liked this

Benjamin Leroux

La Piece Sous le Bois Blagny 1er Cru Pinot Noir 2020

Delectable Wine
9.3

The 2020 Blagny La Piece Sous Le Bois 1er Cru has a lovely bouquet of yellow fruit mixed with wilted white flowers and hazelnut. It's refined with a soupçon of mineralité. The palate nicely balances with real concentration, countervailing acidity and a sapid, focused finish. Impressive in terms of length, this is a superb Meursault that should age with style. This shoots well above the showing from barrel. Tasted blind at the annual Burgfest tasting. (Neal Martin, Vinous, July 2024)
— 3 months ago