ESF

9.1

This was impressive & fun: it pours pale yellowish green and immediately throws grapefruit & ginger, just so floral - jasmine & honeysuckle like some Gewurz I’ve had. Lime peel, saline, salty & surly - terrific nose whose flavors were mirrored on palate. Great acidic backbone, kinda nervy but also nice mouthfeel. Just a pleasurable experience — 7 months ago

Big Wave Dave

9.2

Still a bit surly but massive potential. A big and serious nose of reductive smoke, apple, cut grass, and lemon. This is a full bodied powerful wine but there is still a feeling that there is more to come once this properly unfurls. Sour apple, mealy bread, wrapped in toffee. Creamy, but with a solid steak of sour acidity. Amazing length. True GC structure but 5+ years to truly express itself. — 2 years ago

Daniel Tan

9.2

Surprisingly young for the 23 years it’s been in the bottle. I suppose there’s fruit, but hard to tell what exactly as not much acid. Ferrous. More surly than bright, but no rough edges. Quite good. — 4 years ago

Al Doyle

9.0

Long acids. Very good. Bought from a great little wine shop in Petworth in the South Downs here in the UK, just after having a fantastic lunch at a spot called E. Street Bar & Grill which is a terrible name for an absolutely exemplary little bistro with great seafood and wine. And with the perfect slightly surly but extremely accommodating and professional French maitre d. Anyway, if you happen to pass through check it out. — a year ago

Melissa Kennedy

8.9

Costco advent calendar- a nice surly! — 2 years ago

with Patrick

Erik Sjolund

9.0

Super citric lemon n very VERY gooseberry. Good acididi n fair body. Surly gain w time but still. — 3 years ago

with Nadja

Lyle Fass

Founder Fass Selections

9.5

This was young and went through many phases of open and closed with no rhyme or reason. This was surly at times and superbly expressive, gritty NSG’ey and also sweet and floral. But also closed shut a few times. It is all there but hold off 3-4 years. — a year ago

Ed Chin

9.3

Stickies have its place. This one surly does though at this point not sure it will live up to the 100pts it was given. — a year ago

Paul Masson

9.2

Surly and reductive upon opening, smacking of leathery barnyard, but there is a sleeping giant below, emerging with notes of blackberry liqueur, black pepper, and smoke. Voluminous. Considerable upside with age (unless the Brett takes over), but for now, give it plenty of air. — 3 years ago

Marty Mathis

9.0

Underwood Mountain Sauv Blanc... Wow! Best SB I’ve tasted all year. Most like Sancerre of any US wine I’ve had. Plenty herbal w/ Cat Pee and snap peas but also super fresh lime flavors and racy acidity. Not for everyone but I was surly impressed. Bravo — 4 years ago