Southold Farm + Cellar

The Devil's Advocate Old Vine Chardonnay

8.818 ratings
9.07 pro ratings
North Fork, Long Island, New York, USA
Chardonnay
Duck, Shellfish, Goose, Mushrooms, Manchego & Parmesan, Game, Pork, Squash & Root Vegetables, Chicken, Turkey, Cheddar & Gruyere, Meaty & Oily Fish, White Fish, Shellfish, Crab & Lobster, Cream Sauces
Top Notes For
Joseph Hernandez

Associate Digital Editor Wine Enthusiast Magazine

9.0

Always surprising freshness and weight, like slightly unripe Bosc pears commingling with dandelion greens.

Always surprising freshness and weight, like slightly unripe Bosc pears commingling with dandelion greens.

Feb 1st, 2015
Joe Carroll

Owner/Wine Director Spuyten Duyvil, Fette Sau, St. Anselm & Gotham Artisanal Provisions

8.6

Has a bit of DMS, without it it would be killer.

Has a bit of DMS, without it it would be killer.

Dec 5th, 2014
Michael Gorton Jr

Could be the perfect Thanksgiving wine. Spicy, juicy, fresh, vibrant, verve, oxidation notes, lees lushness, lemon curd and dried tropical trail mix. Let this get to room temperature and watch it fly. The new way to make chardonnay. #southoldfarm+cellar

Could be the perfect Thanksgiving wine. Spicy, juicy, fresh, vibrant, verve, oxidation notes, lees lushness, lemon curd and dried tropical trail mix. Let this get to room temperature and watch it fly. The new way to make chardonnay. #southoldfarm+cellar

Nov 30th, 2014
Anthony Lombardi

As far as the wine goes- it drinks like coriander infused tropical fruit. A unique expression of Chardonnay from terroir that I know very little about. I don't know all the details, but I do know that this winery is going through a very difficult time right now. Here's hoping all works out for them as in my limited experience, they make great wine & should be able to continue doing so.

As far as the wine goes- it drinks like coriander infused tropical fruit. A unique expression of Chardonnay from terroir that I know very little about. I don't know all the details, but I do know that this winery is going through a very difficult time right now. Here's hoping all works out for them as in my limited experience, they make great wine & should be able to continue doing so.

Mar 19th, 2016
Jared O'Connell

Very cool Chardonnay- drank over two days. First day it was very smokey, also kind of oxidative. Second day some smokiness left to leave a more salty and briney thing with some olives and herbal grassiness. Love it!

Very cool Chardonnay- drank over two days. First day it was very smokey, also kind of oxidative. Second day some smokiness left to leave a more salty and briney thing with some olives and herbal grassiness. Love it!

Oct 6th, 2015
David S

Winter BBQ wine.

Winter BBQ wine.

Nov 30th, 2014
Diana Cho

Disgusting smokiness and killed my palate

Disgusting smokiness and killed my palate

Nov 18th, 2014
roland benedetti

again from Southhold farm, one of the very few LI wine I was interested. Very big on butter this guy! Funky,
tony bit of acidity tho very full.

again from Southhold farm, one of the very few LI wine I was interested. Very big on butter this guy! Funky,
tony bit of acidity tho very full.

Aug 24th, 2014
Laura Maguire

Laura had this 9 years ago

Laura had this 9 years ago

Jul 1st, 2015
Jamil C Williams

General Manager at Silverlake Wine

9.6

Jamil had this 9 years ago

Jamil had this 9 years ago

Jan 8th, 2015