Silver Spur

Rivers-Marie

Silver Eagle Vineyard Pinot Noir 2016

Shay A
9.3

I had a disappointing experience with the 2017 a few months back (I think it was in a dumb phase, because these are normally delicious), and wanted to see how the 2016 fared. I also wanted to compare my GlasVin aromatic burg glass with my new Grassl Cru burg glass.

Classic RM SE wine here. At five years, it’s still voluptuous and rich enough to play to those who enjoy the bigger style but has plenty of acidity and snap on the palate to cater to those who prefer more restraint. It does have some signature blood orange both aromatically and on the palate, along with spice, dark floral tones/potpourri and rich black cherry. Whereas the 2017 showed more cola and menthol, I don’t get that at all here. Bright and lifted overall profile. Quite delicious and will be easily for another 5+yrs.

As an aside, the Grassl Cru glass has a much more narrow rim and makes the aromatics more concentrated than the GlasVin. They both drank similarly. Maybe Grassl for more lean/true burgundy pinots that may need concentration and GlasVin for new world/bigger style pinots since they don’t need as much help in the aromatic department.
— 6 days ago

Paul, Jimmy and 35 others liked this
Tobin Spratte

Tobin Spratte

I ran into an RM Summa Vineyard at the shop today. I blame you for my purchasing it. It's a 2018, so sounds like it needs cellar time. What say you?
Shay A

Shay A Influencer Badge Premium Badge

@Tobin Spratte : Happy to be the reason of your purchase! Not sure what you paid, but the Summa, Summa OV, Occidental and Silver Eagle wines are no brainer wines every year. I’d definitely hold that Summa a few years.
Tobin Spratte

Tobin Spratte

@Shay A the shop had only one case so I had to jump on it. $85. My philosophy is if you pay over $60 for a young red wine, you probably should cellar it. I made the mistake of opening a Pisoni too soon. It was good but not anywhere close to its potential.

Silver Palm

North Coast Cabernet Sauvignon

Smooth with notes of tobacco. — 19 days ago

Silver Ghost

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2016

An amazing Napa cab dark in color with a great nose of blueberries, violets, fruits, mocha and spice. — 12 days ago

Adriano Cammarata
with Adriano
Anthony and David liked this

Silver Trident Winery

Benevolent Dictator Pinot Noir 2017

Bias alert. We love this Pinot. The style and secret vineyards add to the quality. Prime grapes from two distinctive vineyards produces a big red fruit, with layered nuances of butterscotch throughout. — 10 days ago

Silver Trident Winery

Playing with Fire Napa Valley Red Blend 2017

Another local favorite. Secrets be told. Beckstoffer lives quietly inside. Plush. Velvety finish. — 10 days ago

Espuela del Gaucho

Gaucho Spur Limited Edition Malbec

Great wine that is bold then dry — a month ago

Kistler

Cuvée Natalie Silver Belt Vineyard Pinot Noir 2010

Pomegranate, strawberry, some crushed rocks. Awesome pinot — 11 days ago

DAD, Ira and 8 others liked this

Casa Sant' Orsola

Silver Moscato d'Asti

Easy drinking wine. Lemon, apple, honeysuckle. — 17 days ago

Silver Oak

Alexander Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2016

Very pleasing. Chalk. — 6 days ago

Matt liked this

Silver Oak

Napa Valley Cabernet Sauvignon 2011

From cousin Lisa to uncle Kim. Great nose and flavor — 25 days ago

Frank Anders
with Frank
Matt liked this